Poll: The X-Factor 2009 Thread

[rare]

She deserves it. Very unfair to even bring it up. Why would you even need to relate his sexuality to the song he sings. I mean who cares. The guy looked quite taken back by the comment.

 

[/\ndy]

anyone know what she said exactly? i only caught the back of what she was saying, not really sure whats going on?

anyone? just a little confused.

 

[Kell_ee001]

hahahaha! Xtra fector, Holly not getting a word in with the caller ranting

anyone know what she said exactly? i only caught the back of what she was saying, not really sure whats going on?

anyone? just a little confused.

Dannii said that from what she's heard from the papers, he didn't need to bother changing the gender reference in the song. Then pressed it a bit trying to get him to comment.

 

[roid]

hahahaha! Xtra fector, Holly not getting a word in with the caller ranting

Crap i forgot about Xtra Factor! Are they all calling in about Danni?

 

[rare]

Crap i forgot about Xtra Factor! Are they all calling in about Danni?

Nope, I get the feeling the director+crew are trying not to bring it up!!!

 

[blairw]

They wont mention it till simon decides what to do, she could be in serious trouble for that.

 

[knip]

No references in any of the texts scrolling across the bottom to the Danni incident, which frankly I am shocked at, so they must have been told not to print any while they are looking into it.

 

[Kell_ee001]

Danyl himself might not want it bringing up again, but regardless of what's seen on screen I expect Dannii will be in trouble offscreen.

 

[mr tommo]

What a ridiculous comment from Dannii. Surely she knows better than most not to pay attnetion to the media and take it as fact.

That guys whole school were probably watching where he teaches and she just tried to put him down after he'd just made the best performance of the night.

 

[Vixen]

Do i hear something completely different to everyone else when Danyl sings?
I really do not see what all the fuss is about!

I agree with you. He has a very nasal tone to his voice that the judges would normally complain about, I really don't hear anything special.

 

[Chimerical]

Danyl sucks. Just a generic power ballad performance where he sung (screamed) as loud as possible.

If I wanted my ear drums smashed I'd listen to Slipknot.

Kandy Rain f.t.w

 

[xb8browney]

What was Dannii playing at?

I thought they were all poor apart from Danyl and Lucie

 

[roid]

What was Dannii playing at?

I thought they were all poor apart from Danyl and Lucie

And Joe, he was good as well.

I can't believe some people 'don't get' Danyl, he's got a great voice and is a good performer.

 

[JAMAL]

No references in any of the texts scrolling across the bottom to the Danni incident, which frankly I am shocked at, so they must have been told not to print any while they are looking into it.

So one minute you are complaining about Danni bringing it up and the next you are shocked they are not bringing it up

 

[MeatLoaf]

I thought Lucie was the best of the night. The twins wernt as bad as i was expecting but still crap lol

 

[msmalls74]

Danyl (or is it Danelle?) good performance, not great heard that song sang better by "less talented" artist even on this series of Xfactor. He made a decent job but he lacked the emotion and power of the original song, killed a mic stand at the end very classy
Kandy Rain, was pretty average to good, one of the better girl bands to be on xfactor. Thought Cheryl and Danni went far OTT about there outfits, a case of kettle and pot to me, they never mentioned the vocals just the clothes/dance routine.
The twins, oh dear think they will be out unless the tweens keep them in, better than they had been in the other rounds though.
Most of the boys were a bit Meh to me, only the lad from south shields did a good job, but they all do well as they'll get the mum,granny and teenage girl vote.
Jamie, like his rocky style but dont think he'll ever make it as pop star, could do very well as lead vocals for a rock band. Think he will do well, may come unstuck depending on what songs he is given to sing
Stacy, a bit Catherine Tate but i like her voice and she seems very happy to be there and a bit over awed by the whole thing. Id like her to win but i dont think she could cope without an excellent management team and people to give her good advice.
Lucie good vocals but i didnt think she did a great job of the Leona song, perhaps it was just me.
Olly, Did OK would have rather one of the girls got in from the other 25s dont see much great about him, seems a nice chap.
Miss Frank, Liked to see them go far they got a bit of TLC attitude about them, glad she didnt rap as it wouldnt work in that song.

 

[SexyGreyFox]

After listening to Danni 3 times I can't see what the problem is.

She just said "If you believe what you read in the papers you didn't need to change the words" and when asked by an audience member she said "No I don't believe it".

 

[buckeejit]

After listening to Danni 3 times I can't see what the problem is.

She just said "If you believe what you read in the papers you didn't need to change the words" and when asked by an audience member she said "No I don't believe it".

Still no need to bring it up on live tv as it has nothing to do with the music and his lack of talent but then again, if he is what he says he is then why did he look like the world was just about to end? Shock, I highly doubt it as it's apparently been reported in the papers all week, he must have known that someone would eventually ask him.

 

[roid]

After listening to Danni 3 times I can't see what the problem is.

She just said "If you believe what you read in the papers you didn't need to change the words" and when asked by an audience member she said "No I don't believe it".

If she didn't believe it why did she say it then? Seemed like she knew she'd jumped in with both feet and was trying to backpedal.

 

[TurnipHead]

I still don't know what she meant, is he gay? Did he used to be a woman?