Poll: The X-Factor 2009 Thread

[Kell_ee001]

What, I have to be able to sing in order to have an opinion.

How ridiculous.

Calling it "shocking" is ridiculous - not your taste or not as good as others is fair enough, but when you can't even hold a note... that just jealousy talking?

 

[SexyGreyFox]

Come on then, show us you can do better!

You've just sounded like one of those contestants that tells Simon Cowell that he can't sing.

Do I have a right to an opinion? - http://www.disturbinthepeace.co.uk/mp3/media.htm

 

[Azza]

Who is this crow on stage now?

 

[Prophet]

Calling it "shocking" is ridiculous - not your taste or not as good as others is fair enough, but when you can't even hold a note... that just jealousy talking?

So when Simon tells one of them they can't sing he's jealous too?

Overall his vocals are weak, he has poor range and is unable to project his voice.

 

[Gustov]

Calling it "shocking" is ridiculous - not your taste or not as good as others is fair enough, but when you can't even hold a note... that just jealousy talking?

Although everyone is entitled to an opinion I'm with you on this one.

Yes these aren't the best singers in the world but to use such harsh adjectives to describe them is just ridiculous.

They are better than your average singer. I mean go check the Cheryl Cole thread I made on these forums. People are labeling it as 'terrible'.

 

[Kell_ee001]

So when Simon tells one of them they can't sing he's jealous too?

Overall his vocals are weak, he has poor range and is unable to project his voice.

You claiming to be Simon Cowell now?

 

[Prophet]

You claiming to be Simon Cowell now?

No, but you seem to like side stepping what I've written

 

[msmalls74]

SuBo probably would have walked xfactor this year in a pure singing competetion, that version of wild horses was great IMO of course. Reckon Lloyd will be out tonight, or J&E they dont need to win they are going to be snapped up for TV as soon as Simon will let them be.

 

[Prophet]

Although everyone is entitled to an opinion I'm with you on this one.

Yes these aren't the best singers in the world but to use such harsh adjectives to describe them is just ridiculous.

They are better than your average singer. I mean go check the Cheryl Cole thread I made on these forums. People are labeling it as 'terrible'.

But I am shocked how he's made it this far, how he got in the final 12 for that matter.

There were people in the auditions who could sing much better than him who didn't make the second round.

 

[Lakeland]

Why the miming ??

 

[Gustov]

But I am shocked how he's made it this far, how he got in the final 12 for that matter.

There were people in the auditions who could sing much better than him who didn't make the second round.

Same

Regardless, he's not terrible though.

 

[thedinks]

is maria miming?

 

[Gustov]

Seems like she is at times then at other times not ?

EDIT- Yes she is miming.

Good god.

 

[Kell_ee001]

You've just sounded like one of those contestants that tells Simon Cowell that he can't sing.

Do I have a right to an opinion? - snip[ /url][/QUOTE] Sorry, missed ...far and not Lloyds voice that is shocking? :p

 

[Lakeland]

is maria miming?

for about 90% of it yeh! shocking

 

[Azza]

What on Earth just happened?!?


Auto-tune at it's best.

 

[doodah]

She has to be! She does it all the time! When I look back in 50 years time, can't believe she will be labelled as one of the most successive female artists

 

[Bucket]

aaaaaaawful.

 

[Gustov]

I WISH they made Muse mime on the X Factor.

That would make my day

 

[Prophet]

Not side stepping, just ignoring a statement that was as ridiculous as your previous ones

And you think I'm talking rubbish lol.

And now backtracking. So you're shocked at how he got so far and not Lloyds voice that is shocking?

No, these are in addition to thinking his voice is shocking.

I take it you're a fan of Lloyd?