Top Gear Season 14

Loved the episode

Couldnt help but think that they've turned off everything in the X6 than just stuck it on some loose ground and nailed the throttle to make the point that its not as good as the rangerover

Adjustable height control - not needed to go up a slight grassy slope. Hill descent control - again not needed to go up a grassy hill. Locking differential, again not needed to up a grassy hill iirc ?

I bet the X6 is far better on snow and grass than they made out, but again turned everything off to make the point in an easy to understand way for the viewers.

The X6 doesn't have locking diffs so they wouldn't have turned them off, the main reason the car got stuck on the grass and snow is that it was running summer tyres. If they had compared it to a 2WD car that probably wouldn't have got in the field and been at the bottom of the snow covered road.

The tyres make a huge difference in the long termer test in Evo a Range Rover was crawling up a hill in the Alps spinning all four wheels when a 306 or 307 went round it as it was running winter tyres compared to the summer tyres on the Range Rover
 
Last edited:
would the rangerover have breezed up the hill the way it did on summer tyres too though ?

With the diffs locked I suspect it would have made it, the one they used may have even been on summer tyres although most of the Range Rovers with the smaller wheels come with all terrain tyres.

The Range Rover is a proper off roader where the X6 is a car jacked up with 4WD I don't even think it has a low range gearbox it will however still go further than a 2WD car. It wasn't really a fair comparison they should have had a 5 series and seen how far that got however the point they were showing well is that from the factory the X6 is no off roader.
 
Last edited:
would the rangerover have breezed up the hill the way it did on summer tyres too though ?

Do not underestimate what a range rover can do. (Also in the sticks, don't over estimate either :O )

check these. I couldn't find the clip I was looking specifically for, but these show what it can do. Look how the wheels spin but it still crawls forward. Look at the traction provided when climbing the steep hill.

The rangie makes all these look too easy.






 
we know that the Rangerover and the Disco are very good offroad, but it all depends on the spec

As already posted ive heard stories of range rover sports doing exactly the same as the X6 given the slightest snowly incline, so i was a bit skeptical to see the RR breeze up the hill and the X6 languish there.

If it turns out the RR sport is fitted with summer road tyres out of the factory, and the normal range rover has all terrain tyres out of the factory, then that would go someway to explaining it all.
 
Loved the episode

Couldnt help but think that they've turned off everything in the X6 than just stuck it on some loose ground and nailed the throttle to make the point that its not as good as the rangerover

Adjustable height control - not needed to go up a slight grassy slope. Hill descent control - again not needed to go up a grassy hill. Locking differential, again not needed to up a grassy hill iirc ?

Locking diff will mean you have to get all the wheels spinning to get wheelspin, the X6 just lost grip and one and had no torque to transmit to the others. No low ratio to down gear the torque at the wheels either.
 
we know that the Rangerover and the Disco are very good offroad, but it all depends on the spec

As already posted ive heard stories of range rover sports doing exactly the same as the X6 given the slightest snowly incline, so i was a bit skeptical to see the RR breeze up the hill and the X6 languish there.

The range Rover probably would have done the same with a snowy incline
 
what exactly does the locking diff do, i thought it did as the name sounded and just locked the diff up.

But does low ratio do anything you couldnt do yourself just by being gentle with the throttle ?
 
Back
Top Bottom