Why are we afraid of fish?

Soldato
Joined
29 Jun 2004
Posts
12,957
We're an island nation surrounded by sea and amazing varieties of fish. As a nation I don't think we eat enough of it. It can be cheap too. I just bought a whole fresh trout for £1.80! Plus fish is dead easy to make.

What's the issue?
 
Fashion, class etc
It's just like offal, loads of stuff fell out of fashion and I think initially it had a lot to do with class/wealth and people not wanting to be seen as poor, since then we've had the whole, it's disgusting, people won't eat stuff on bones and off course lost cooking skills and recipes.

I cant find razor clams :( or chicken hearts :(

I'm also finding it hard to find out exactly how animals are reared, even the organic/welfare orientated farms, massive about us page, rarely give the details, which is disappointing.

Oops a little off topic.
 
Last edited:
I feel the same!

A nice slab of cod or pollock or plaice with a soft poached egg is just amazing, sooo much flavour from just 2 ingredients.. so clean..... (dribbles a little)

I will be looking at a seafood based dish tomorrow but cannot decide what to do as I am only limited to Tesco's selection. So wish I lived near the coast again.:(
 
I'm fairly lucky we have a proper fishmonger 3 miles away and Eastbourne, Newhaven and Hove are 30 minutes away and all have straight off the boat fish and shellfish.

I've eaten fish all my life and have included it in my kids diet so they are quite happy with fish my wife on the other hand thought fish was battered only and when I gave here a whole fish baked attacked it like eating a steak. She's much better now.

I cry when I go to France and see the fishmonger spreads even in a hypermarche, so lovely.
 
Because it's slimey basically.... Or looks too natural- it's not in plastic packs so you don't have to think about where it's from or what it is or how it was made.

It's impossible to tell the provenance of any meats now really...

I love fish and regularly buy it because it's cheap, healthy and damn tasty.

I think people think it's hard to prepare or hard to cook.
 
Fashion, class etc
It's just like offal, loads of stuff fell out of fashion and I think initially it had a lot to do with class/wealth and people not wanting to be seen as poor, since then we've had the whole, it's disgusting, people won't eat stuff on bones and off course lost cooking skills and recipes.

I cant find razor clams :( or chicken hearts :(

I'm also finding it hard to find out exactly how animals are reared, even the organic/welfare orientated farms, massive about us page, rarely give the details, which is disappointing.

Oops a little off topic.

People choose what to eat based on fashion or class? I've never heard of such concept before :confused:.
Surely people just eat what they like the taste of.

Assuming I cared, where can I find a list of what food is "in fashion" or a list of food that certain classes can/should eat? ;)
 
People choose what to eat based on fashion or class? I've never heard of such concept before :confused:.
Surely people just eat what they like the taste of.

Assuming I cared, where can I find a list of what food is "in fashion" or a list of food that certain classes can/should eat? ;)

Really.
Why do you think salmon is so popular, then you have things like oysters, which have done a total 180 from poor protein packer to fashionable high end delicacy.
Many many other examples of this.

Just as certain styles of cooking have gone in and out of fashion over the years, individual ingredients, too, have their moments in the sun. These tend to run in shorter cycles, but can often take on such a ubiquitous character that we can be left wondering how we ever managed without them.
Meats are no longer just elemental categories, but come with specific designations: Angus beef, Old Spot pork, English rose veal, Anjou pigeon. Ingredients from other cultures can become rapidly assimilated too – witness the indispensability of chorizo.
The nation’s favourite restaurant shellfish, the scallop, has reigned supreme on menus for some years now, teamed not long ago with black pudding, now more often with a vegetable purée.
Vegetables have their moments too. The Jerusalem artichoke, a boon during winter scarcity, has been brought in from the cold. Beetroot has been rescued from the pickle jar, while rhubarb rules the roost from starters through to dessert.

Dessert ingredients are probably the least susceptible to voguishness (notwithstanding the brief tonka bean craze), perhaps because chocolate, toffee and dairy richness never go out of fashion.

Fashion plays a huge part in cooking and ingrediants. If you watch cooking shows go to certain restraints, these trends are very easy to see.
 
Last edited:
Well apart from fish and chips and fish fingers which are hugely popular.


I love fish and have really enjoyed fishing the sea and eating the spoils. Making my own tar tare sauce which is lovely and zesty to go with it. I'd love to build a smoker for all the mackerel that I will catch in the spring/summer.
 
Really.
Why do you think salmon is so popular, then you have things like oysters, which have done a total 180 from poor protein packer to fashionable high end delicacy.
Many many other examples of this.



Fashion plays a huge part in cooking and ingrediants. If you watch cooking shows go to certain restraints, these trends are very easy to see.

Ok, I suppose some people choose what to eat based on what is regarded as being in fashion, class based, trending etc.

I still find it surprising though.
 
£1.80? You can get one pound fish!

On a more serious note, I think a lot are just afraid of cooking it. Too little and afraid they will die, too much and it can ruin a nice piece.
 
It's just how humans are, we are sheep in so many ways. We follow the hird.

Hey Glaucus, I've just been thinking about this, and maybe more people choose what to eat based on the reasons you put forward than I thought.

When doing the shopping, I'm always on on the lookout for something new/different, but it's usually the same old same.

At times I see something new, but usually they aren't stocked for long (probably due to lack of demand because of people not being prepared to experiment due to the sheep mentality that you mentioned).

There again, how would new "fashions" or "trends" develop without people experimenting. (arggg, my brain just exploded) :(

Apologies to the OP for going OT.
For the record I like and eat fish :)
 
Big lover of fish here, fresh water or sea fish. Used to do an awful lot of fly fishing years ago. Great sport with a tasty meal at the end of it. The river that flows through my village is pretty highly regarded for the quality of it's salmon and brown trout.

We in the uk tend to disregard a lot of the species in our local waters. Quite a lot of fish that is caught ends up on the continent. Europeans seem to be more willing to try different varieties of fish.
 
There again, how would new "fashions" or "trends" develop without people experimenting. (arggg, my brain just exploded) :(

Media
High end restraunts
Celebrity chefs

Heston is a great example as he changed so much, a few things have stuck (like double/triple cooked chips at gastro pubs) but most of it has died out at least in the publics interest and just seen as over the top.
 
I've got mackerel for breakfast tomorrow morning :D


I think fish is out of fashion nowadays because it smells a fair bit, and looks like the animal it is.
I'm sure one of the reasons salmon is so popular is because you buy it in fillets rather than as a whole fish. There has also been a decline in sales of whole chickens at the same time as an increase in sales of chicken breast and wings.

Modern people like to forget that meat comes from animals it seems.
 
I like the unpopularity of meat on the bone.

Chicken wings and thoughts are so cheap.

100% free ranged chicken wings 5 for £1:20, bargain.
 
Because it's slimey basically.... Or looks too natural- it's not in plastic packs so you don't have to think about where it's from or what it is or how it was made.

It's impossible to tell the provenance of any meats now really...

I love fish and regularly buy it because it's cheap, healthy and damn tasty.

I think people think it's hard to prepare or hard to cook.

I get all my meat from a local butchers, and I still don't do fish.

It's nothing to do with how it looks, or how it's presented, I simply can't stomach most sea food, the smell alone is often enough to get me feeling sick.
 
I eat tinned mackerel/sardines and fresh salmon fillet, occasionally cod. I never really venture out from that, not sure why! I think it might be because there's no prep involved (lazy I know!).

Saying that though, I might take a peek at the fish counter more often now as I really like fresh mackerel and trout.
 
I eat tinned mackerel/sardines and fresh salmon fillet, occasionally cod. I never really venture out from that, not sure why! I think it might be because there's no prep involved (lazy I know!).

Saying that though, I might take a peek at the fish counter more often now as I really like fresh mackerel and trout.
No haddock?

Haddock is my personal favorite, either battered, bread crumbed or smoked.
 
Back
Top Bottom