Why MPG and not MPL

Man of Honour
Joined
25 Oct 2002
Posts
31,742
Location
Hampshire
That explains why so many people are struggling with it. Complex maths. lol.

Since when was basic division and multiplication, complex maths.

It's not 'complex' in mathematical terms but you need to bear in mind that Joe Public just wants to make quick and easy comparisons without having to think about it. MPG is sort of like an inverse cost curve which for people who don't stop and think could deliver this 'illusion' around the benefits of very high MPG. If you asked the average guy on the street if they would save us much going from 50mpg to 60mpg as they do from going from 40mpg to 50mpg, without giving it any thought, a fair few would probably say "yes because it's improved by 10mpg in both cases" or similar.

Litres per mile or litres per 100 miles is what I would go with. Get rid of gallons.
 
Man of Honour
Joined
25 Oct 2002
Posts
31,742
Location
Hampshire
It's very rare in motoring terms that I see any fractional measures of miles used other than halves or quarters though. Sat Navs / google maps typically use decimals, road signs generally use whole miles except for backwater lanes maybe go down to say 3/4 mile or whatever. OK so you get signs on the approach to junctions maybe indicating hundreds of yards but I don't think that has any bearing in how we look at fuel consumption, it's more to alert the driver how far to the junction.
 
Soldato
Joined
8 Nov 2006
Posts
22,979
Location
London
I don't want to be doing complex maths when trying to compare how much a 1000 miles a month is gonna cost me to drive a certain car.

http://www.mpgillusion.com/p/what-is-mpg-illusion.html

This website also explains well why MPG comparisons are misleading.

That explains why so many people are struggling with it. Complex maths. lol.

Since when was basic division and multiplication, complex maths.

It isn't that it it is complex.

It is completely unintuitive.

The example they gave would have taken me a minute to work out, even though they picked a nice round example.

Whilst with l/100km (or gallons per mile) it would take me 3 seconds.

If I took 3 seconds to guess the MPG example, I would probably get it wrong.
 
Back
Top Bottom