Perhaps.... What is clear is that Microsoft royally screwed up the announcements and communications. I can't help but feel that if they had have done the E3 gaming stuff first, and later added a "and as well as gaming it can do all this" for the TV/Media stuff they'd have done a lot better.
The same happened with the digital licensing/sharing, MS have only themselves to blame for screwing up the communication of what could have been an interesting and, perhaps with a few tweaks, well received initiative. I don't think MS are out to screw gamers Xbox and 360 have been good examples of a decent gaming platform, with, for me, the right balance of managed control with Live and elbow room for devs etc through arcade and other areas.
Unfortunately they tried to dribble out news on the capabilities of XB1 and before they clarified and posted details on the proposed system and why it was good for gamers the lynch mob had got hold of it and no one was listening any longer. You only have to look at the amount of conversations that started with "I won't buy an Xbox one, you can't trade or sell games" long after it had been clarified that you could indeed sell games.
**** poor communications and marketing by MS and it's going to take quite some time to turn it around.
Funnily enough I read today the new Android powered Motorola X phone will have always on "passive" listening for voice commands. Alongside an "always on" internet connection, permanent location awareness for mobile operators, google analytics for advertising etc and integral camera it all sounds remarkably familiar. As far as I can tell there's been no fuss whatsoever though, not sure who that says more about, a distrust of MS or just a sensitivity from console gamers.
Perhaps MS just tried to do too much too fast and then fudged the comms missing the opportunity to tell why it was safe and an advantage for gamers rather than a perceived advantage to MS/NSA/Kitch9 and his willy pictures/publishers etc...
In any case glad to see Mattrick has gone and hopefully the new boss is taking a long hard look at the Xbox marketing and PR teams.