It really is nothing like the whole squad being bad, I've said so many times this year, against most teams you can cost with maybe 2/3 bad players in the team, one two others underperforming. WE've won games big with Denilson, Song and Diaby playing like against Stoke. But that same type of setup against the top 4, of Champs league, we get destroyed. 3 players can make ALL the difference, against a team with 11 players all performing if you have 2 bad performances you could have a problem.
utd, as liverpool have coasted many games this year with Giggs, Anderson, Tevez all playing horribly poorly, in other games they've played well, thats life. But on the biggest stage, at this point in his career Giggs simply isn't good enough anymore, Tevez never was and Anderson never will be.
Think about the big games recently, how many games have Utd struggled only to take off the likes of Anderson, Rafael, Giggs or Nani and turned a game around, Spurs being the biggest and most obvious. Carrick was fantastic second half where he played his role, first half Anderson was woeful leaving the big gaping hole that Modric ran through at will unchecked and useless going forwards. His defensive play is terrible, he chases the ball rather than is infront of it.
As much as I don't really think Macherano is a great player on the ball, and he's a dirty dirty little git, the one thing he does know is how to be between the ball and the goal, Utd and Arsenal desparately missed that in their biggest games of the year.
The reason Arsenal got crushed in the semi's, Anderson might suck, just not as badly as our holy trinity of turdness.
For all the people who have a massive go and calling Rio/Vidic crap. Lets be honest, they were only turned several times in the game and the whole back line turned away FAR more attacks than got through. Such is life, the best defenders in the world will never be capable of stopping every attack. Vidic got turned, by one of the best strikers the game has seen, many other times Eto'o was stopped.
Defensive weakness's weren't the issue, though Evra and o'shea weren't great, Henry skinned O'shea, well, less times than I can count on one hand, thats not terrible.
It was the lack of real chances from in the box Utd created, and the lack of real posession and that was lost in midfield and upfront.
Anderson and Giggs out of that game and the result "could" have been incredibly different.
Theres no need to panic, Vidic and Rio did pretty well against the most prolific front 3 in the world this season, O'shea, no where near first choice, did ok, the only performances that were actually terrible, where Anderson(in his prefered role according to most) and Giggs.
I also agree Quieroz is needed, Utd's defence went crap and mostly the midfield pair didn't seem to know how to defend when McClaren left the first time, and once Quieroz was installed that came back, he's left, and that ability has left the team again.
Its something Fergie isn't able to get out of his players and needs replacing asap, how he didn't learn from the previous troubles that Quieroz needed a proper replacement instantly i don't know. Nor can I explain his ridiculous starting team, live and learn, even the greatest people make mistakes.