The poster you're quoting didn't say that or even anything to that effect..
better tell Tom that also then:
As for the rest, reserve team football is of a worst standard that league 1 so nothing anyone ever does there really means anything
Personally think my comment was more than valid - but you are welcome to your opinion

I don't think Evra will go to be honest; he's probably angling for a last big payday from the club. He's getting older now and probably realises that he won't get paid more or play at a higher level at another club so he's more than likely looking for a contract extension with a generous wage.
And good servant or not in previous campaigns, I hope Carrick is sold on by the end of this Summer.
Seeing as its RM thats being interested in getting him, he will certainly be paid more - at an equally high level - but potentially a better quality of life, so yes there is every chance he could move. If he was just after a hike in wages, given the amount of 1st team games he playes (at a guess 90% + he is available for), the club would have dealt with it ages ago Im sure. Like Carrick he only has 18 months left on his contract (I believe), so its being left REALLY late for such a high performer imo
Didn't say that.... but Obertan showed potential. Most the time, if someone does well for the reserves, they can be brought into the first team. Hell, I'd rather see Obertan and Bebe on the bench instead of the likes of Gibson and Carrick.
As above, I wasnt the only person to think you implied that
Obertan has also had quite a few EPL games to show what he can do, and it isnt very much. I dont rate Gibson at all (even though he seemed to do ok yesterday), but Carrick has been doing well recently with some assists and crucial interceptions
Im sure SAF has a much clearer indication in training whether any player can hack it in the EPL
Last edited: