I personally think Shane is the best so far, I really like his darker side and things should be interesting between him and Rick, Dale and Andrea now I reckon.
I also don't get why Hershel is so against them staying, not like their all in the same house together or completely disrespecting him and the rest, obeying his rules so far, which IMO are pretty much too much i.e. all guns to be handed over as Rick and Shane said what happens if a herd of walkers come to the farm at night when their sleeping or the walkers get out of the barn when their sleeping, they won't have their guns with them at all to defend themselves and knowing Hershel he would probably lock them in the house somewhere, which only he knew where they were and had the only key to gaining access to them.
I also don't get why Hershel is so against them staying, not like their all in the same house together or completely disrespecting him and the rest, obeying his rules so far, which IMO are pretty much too much i.e. all guns to be handed over as Rick and Shane said what happens if a herd of walkers come to the farm at night when their sleeping or the walkers get out of the barn when their sleeping, they won't have their guns with them at all to defend themselves and knowing Hershel he would probably lock them in the house somewhere, which only he knew where they were and had the only key to gaining access to them.



).