Have to say I didn't find the Ed Sheeran scene that jarring though it would have been completely fine to cut it entirely - the only thing I found obnoxious was that is dragged on longer than it needed just because it was Ed Sheeran seemingly.
Poll: Winter Is Coming - HBO's A Game of Thrones [READ WARNING]
- Thread starter Hostile_18
- Start date
They are pretty on point for most of it - but that stuff with the dragons and scorpions is explained albeit it is pretty hard to believe they managed to sneak up in range to hit dragons with those ships in the first place - in the first attack the dragons are at an altitude and distance that makes them easy targets in the second instance Daenerys purposefully comes in fast and high using the sun to her advantage and then flies below the level of maximum depression.
Soldato
Again - I don't think it was that bad in the context. The whole scene is pretty poor and slow-paced, but that's a million miles away from series 8.
I support things like this if done well (or not poorly), to bring in a whole new audience to the show. Which in this case it did, IIRC.
You’re still missing the point. Jon didn’t want to be King. Rather than assuming bad in everyone’s motives (his family and Tyrian) look at it the other way:
He didn’t want to be king of the North and was very vocal about it to everyone, including Sansa.
He didn’t want to be King of the Seven Kingdoms when he found out he was the “true heir”. He told Bran and Sam when he found out. He told Sanasa and Arya when they found out. He told Tyrian when he found out. He told Danny when she found out. Basically he told everyone that would listen that he didn’t want to be king.
Conversely he made great friends with the wildlings and it was obvious he would rather be with them than King.
So win win situation. The family and Tyrian don’t nominate the obvious choice of Jon (who most still don’t know is a Targaryen) because it would cause problems And he didn’t want to be king. Instead they send him to the non existent Nights Watch to be with friends, while tricking the army that has him captive. Bear in mind Bran is now king so if Jon wanted to come back it wouldn’t be inconceivable for him to change the rules even a few months later (after Greyworm and the Dothraki have gone).
To me that ending is far more true to the characters than the idea of Jon ending up as king.
Soldato
Where's the applause emoji when you need it?
Not everyone is obsessed with him as you. I watched that scene and it was fine, but then I didn’t know what he looked like.
Now, because of people like you, when I watch that scene all I can think of is angry people on the internet.
You've literally just said why it was fine for you. Just because you didn't know what one of the biggest musicians out there looked like doesn't mean most people watching didn't. Seeing someone so famous front and centre for a cameo is jarring as hell.
Commissario
By that standard you'd best never have any well known actors in anything, ever.
Once you're a known face you're going to ruin anything else you're in.
It's jarring to see Sean Bean in a medieval setting, we all know he was Napoleonic, and Lena Headey should be in Sci Fi not Fantasy as she's well known for being Sarah Connor.
Oddly enough when watching a TV series or film you sort of expect to have faces that ring a bell from other things, it's a rare actor or actress who can (without major prosthetics covering their face) hide who they are if they've ever played the lead in something big, or that you've enjoyed.
I wouldn't have recognised Sheeran except my brother mentioned it (and he only knew because he'd read about a cameo), as oddly enough not everyone is into pop music.
Sorry but this is bad logic. Ed Sheertan was obviously sticking out like a sore thumb because everyone knows he is not an actor, but one of, if not THE most recognisable modern musician in the world. You cannot suspend disbelief seeing him there playing an instrument and singing for one scene when it is 100% obvious to anyone with half a brain that he is just there to make a cameo, not to act. To even compare this to Shaun Bean acting in different roles is very silly.
Last edited:
Soldato
Do you know much about the unsullied? They are literally just warrior eunuchs. The show has humanised Grey Worm somewhat, but they are basically akin to stormtroopers, or a droid army. They were always slaves until Daenerys 'freed' them. It says on the GoT wiki 'their actions will only go as far as what they have been ordered to do, and nothing more'. They aren't rulers. They would have no idea how to rule, they have no families to care about, will obviously bear no kids etc. Literally their only purpose is fighting. With Daenerys gone, this leaves them with literally no one to fight for. And for them, that means nothing to fight for.
They don't want to hold power because they don't care about it and it means nothing to them. Sansa, Bran, Edmure et al didn't kill Daenerys, Jon did. They are obviously bearing a lot of ill will towards Jon and Tyrion, as clearly shown in that scene. But why must they bear ill will towards the rest of the lords? Grey Worm isn't an idiot, he recognises someone who knows something about ruling needs to be in charge, and the lords in this scene know more about that than anyone. Hence he doesn't/can't come up with a better suggestion than what Tyrion puts forward. Power resides where men believe it resides, remember.
If you have a scene with some randoms and a song that needs singing well then having a musician do it isn't a bad idea.
Having said that it did pull me out of the scene a little bit although I wasn't that fussed. Think they should have buried him under prosthetics or something.
"Poor Ed" having half his face burned off by a dragon was a nod from the makers that it probably wasn't the best idea to have him front and centre.
Having said that it did pull me out of the scene a little bit although I wasn't that fussed. Think they should have buried him under prosthetics or something.
"Poor Ed" having half his face burned off by a dragon was a nod from the makers that it probably wasn't the best idea to have him front and centre.
Associate
Bit late to review, but was disappointed with the last episode. Seems like they had 8 seasons of build up and apart from the Night King, decided to try and end everything in one episode.
But hey, it was a hell of a ride and we had some fantastic episodes a long the way.
All the supposedly humorous parts felt massively out of place and were so cringe-worthy. Why is everyone so relaxed when there is possibly the biggest power vacuum ever to try and resolve?
The pacing of Jon going from "she is my queen" to murdering Dany in 5 minutes and after one conversation felt ridiculous. At least I was mildly excited about what would happen afterwards, but then we just skipped forward three weeks, so didn't get to see anything.
Dany's demise, Jon going back to the wall and Bran becoming King just felt massively underwhelming and almost like the writers couldn't be bothered at the end.
The pacing of Jon going from "she is my queen" to murdering Dany in 5 minutes and after one conversation felt ridiculous. At least I was mildly excited about what would happen afterwards, but then we just skipped forward three weeks, so didn't get to see anything.
Dany's demise, Jon going back to the wall and Bran becoming King just felt massively underwhelming and almost like the writers couldn't be bothered at the end.
But hey, it was a hell of a ride and we had some fantastic episodes a long the way.
Soldato
That video is spot on!
After S8, Ed Sheeran being in it is the least of the show's problems!
After S8, Ed Sheeran being in it is the least of the show's problems!
Soldato
Did you not feel like he'd been wondering if he really did support her, deep down, for a little while? At the very least since he found out he is a Targaryen it's clear he's been having a couple of mixed emotions. Clearly he is someone who loyalty means a lot to. You could see in his face in the scene with Tyrion that he knew what needed to be done (and probably did from the moment she started torching the street), but saying it out loud is a different thing. You can tell he was still full of remorse at the time of doing it too. So I disagree that in 5 minutes he went from unquestionable loyal subject to OK I'll murder you no probs.
Man of Honour
- Joined
- 21 Nov 2004
- Posts
- 45,003
Yup. Perfect.
The Dothraki charged in, all died, sacked king’s landing 2 episodes later, and then assimilated into Westerosi culture an episode after that (to become farmers?).
I love this comment
Last edited:
TBF I found it more jarring when Lovejoy turned up
Soldato
Exactly. People are just looking for things to hate. They probably complained about the Daniel Craig and Simon Pegg cameos in Star Wars too.