It's nothing to do with me being wrong, it's the impression that the crop gives. You are not exactly going to show the viewer a before and after for every shot to prove them wrong.
Neither of these shots warrants that kind of crop, the one in the field is a much much stronger photo with the sky and the weird face one you cropped out the glass because it is distracting...so crop it out normally, don't need to be "cinematic"
The B&W a few posts above is a stunner Robbie, absolutely love the lighting and you've captured it perfectly.