Man of Honour
Damn I voted a 1 before I realized there was a fix option
Poll: Abu Dhabi Grand Prix 2021, Yas Island - Race 22
- Thread starter Shimmy
- Start date
- Status
Caporegime
Terrible if you're a Hamilton/Mercedes fan, amazing if you're a Max/Red Bull fan or neutral. I couldn't have wished for a better end to the season other than Norris winning.
Soldato
I really wanted Lewis to get 8 championships and then I wouldn't have minded Max winning next year. I wonder if Lewis can still do it in 2022.
He left the track because he was again forced off it. He could have turned into a Redbull instead. I think most people would therefore drive off the track.
Having the race settled after the fact and in court would be very uninspiring and contentious regardless of whether it was right or wrong for a lot of people.
I do agree he was the rightful winner of that race but just how I imagine it would be portrayed. The whole thing has a bad feeling surrounding it now whatever the outcome (i expect nothing)
Soldato
Same here...
There are no guarantees - but you work, over years, to construct a rule book to deliver exciting races. You don't abandon rules at the drop of a hat for cheap thrills.
Soldato
Any worse by RB winning through the rules not being adhered to?
No more contentious than the race director making up imaginary rules to gift the race to Max.
That would be a failure for the FIA. Not for Hamilton and Mercedes.
It's also not RBR's fault. They tried everything they could, but ultimately play by the same rules.
To be fair Masi et al could’ve avoided this situation by not creating a situation that could be protested…
Yep, I missed Fix.
Soldato
I'm a McLaren fan and neither a Lewis or Max fan but wanted Max to win - but I think this is a terrible ending.
Soldato
Mate, teams put millions of pounds into this stuff. That doesn't wash I'm afraid.
Soldato
If the roles were reversed, would there be a 'fix' option I wonder?
Soldato
Red flagging the race and giving us a 4 lap shootout would have been the least bad way to decide it.
Lewis could have changed his tyres and we'd have had a straight fight.
There's gonna be no winners now whatever the outcome. Max wins and it's always a bit contentious, Lewis wins and it's 100x more contentious.
Lewis could have changed his tyres and we'd have had a straight fight.
There's gonna be no winners now whatever the outcome. Max wins and it's always a bit contentious, Lewis wins and it's 100x more contentious.
As a neutral I'm not sure. Yes it's great that they tried to get racing done asap. On balance Red Bull took the risks and succeeded. Hamilton was faster overall. Do I think it's becoming more like WWE :shurgs:
Soldato
I think Merc should just pull out of F1. They don't need it and its probably costing them money to be there...
Associate
- Joined
- 21 Jun 2004
- Posts
- 1,605
Agree handing back wouldn’t have changed outcome, but that was a substantial advantage from leaving the track that wasn’t punished or investigated.
For the overtake I don’t think MV needs to leave much space, LH has lost the corner already due to his position/line of entry and MV massive pace and grip advantage due to tyres. LH wouldn’t have been able to stay on the outside pace wise anyway, which is why he cut back to get a better line for the next corner as he knew he couldn’t fit staying on the outside line.
edit - this move is different to previous as MV has stayed on track throughout the move and has been ahead going in to the corner on the racing line, so not comparable to the previous races where he couldn’t slow it down and drove LH (and himself) off the track.
I think the best chance Merc have is the restart process rather than anything on track. For me none of the Mv driving would particularly give a penalty. Though we still have scrutinering (sp?) to throw a spanner in the work potentially!
- Status