Associate
"Whilst it is possible to buy a FE, due to how quickly they go out of stock, it is very hard to get one, not impossible, however, you will have a better chance of buying an overpriced AIB compared to FE"
A mostly accurate statement.
A given AIB card may or may not be overpriced compared to an FE card, depending on what value an individual may place on the features that the AIB card provides in contrast to the FE card - e.g. cooler, power, even RGB. But availability is also one of those features - if an individual needs a card now (for whatever reason - that's their choice), then the price of the FE card is completely irrelevant (i.e. "fake") because they can't buy one right now[1].
Maybe create a thread for rdna 2 to see just how many people in the UK managed to get "MBA" for MSRP, I would certainly be interested in seeing them figures
Alert! Goalposts moved! You didn't mention specifically getting an MBA card for MSRP. I'll quote your statement again:
No doubting if you wanted to buy a FE, you would have had to sign up to telegram etc. same way you also had to do the same for rdna 2 and even consoles last year.
No mention of MBA or MSRP in that blanket statement. That statement - that you had to sign up for alerts to get an rdna 2 card is just as false as the statements to which you are objecting.
Again, read this:
If people chose to pay AIB prices or/and not hold out for nvidia FE, that is their choice.
To use your words back at you.
Again you are missing the point:
if you want to make a sound price comparison you need to compare products that are similarly available to you to buy. That means AIB to AIB. Not AIB to FE and likely not MBA to FE either. Not until FE cards and MBA cards are properly in stock.
You can't reasonably claim an AIB AMD card is automatically poor value against the price of an FE card if you could get the AMD card tomorrow, but might not get lucky with the FE card for months. That is imposing your own value-judgement on availability onto others.
[1] Well unless a 3090Ti meets their other requirements, because that's the only FE card that you can actually buy at the time of writing this.