I would just say no. There is little point in the FSI non turbo. It will be soulless and slow, and not feel even remotely quick, whilst returning poor mpg. Poorer in fact than the turbo one, because you'll have to wring its neck everywhere to get it to shift.
I would say, if you can't afford the TFSI now, then don't buy the car now. Save a little more and wait. No point in compromising on the engine IMO, not without a reason anyway.
I hear you, and appreciate the input.
Although I would argue that while it may feel soul-less and slow to some people, it is less likely to feel that way to me considering the car I would be coming from.
I currently drive a 1.2 Polo 9N, which has 53.6 BHP according the the handbook, I admit that I chuckled a little when you said that I'll have to wring it's neck everywhere to get it to shift. That is true of the Polo, with its 17.9 second 0-60 time, but I still get it to shift, sometimes by welding the pedal to the floor and quick shifting.
A 10 second car would be an absolute breath of fresh air and I think the amount of power would be very comfortable for a long while.
Also bearing in mind the fact that I will most likely be spending a maximum of £4500, I'd rather get a good example of a 2.0 FSI than a lesser example of a 2.0 TFSI, but as I said before, we shall see what happens. I still need to test drive these, and a few other cars, before I can take any further steps with my decision making.
What of the fuel economy then? You say it is about the same as the TFSI, but in the real world, what does that translate to? I never trust quoted MPG figures from the manufacturer, as so far at least they all seem to be incredibly ambitious. (particularly BMW's figures I have to say)
The 2.0 FSI is also considerably less to insure, and I'm not sure that in the event of a claim, I'd be able to insure the 2.0T because of the increase in insurance cost as a result, whereas the 2.0 FSI non turbo would probably be more manageable. Insurance is a major factor in my choice at my age. (19 w' 1yr NCB)
And was I right in thinking that the engine has to be run on super?