I’m talking specifically about the 5 Series not adaptive systems in general.
There are two systems offered on the 5 Series – Variable Damper Control and Adaptive Drive.
Variable Damper Control is an Adaptive setup based on the SE suspension. It has 20mm higher ride height than an M Sport car and a VDC fitted car in Sport mode does not offer equivalent ride and handling to a passive M Sport suspension fitted car. Think of it is a comfortable suspension that can be made a bit firmer, not a ‘sporty’ suspension that can be made more comfortable. A car fitted with just VDC does not handle as well as a car fitted with passive M Sport suspension and exhibits more body roll etc.
Adaptive Drive adds Dynamic Drive to the Variable Damper Control which gives the cars electronically controlled hydraulic anti rollbars as well as the adaptive dampers. This system is excellent and absolutely does offer the best of all worlds – great handling but with the option of more comfort when needed.
So, the magazines go on and on and on about how adaptive suspension is ‘essential’ on the F10 yet 9/10 they are reviewing the 520d – a car for which Adaptive Drive was never offered and the only choice available was VDC which IMHO is an inferior setup to a passive M Sport car. The passive M Sport setup already offers a good compromise between ride and handling. You cannot get more comfort without either compromising the cars handling or going for the full on Adaptive Drive system which is very rare on a used car. A lot of people make the assumption that VDC alone is a ‘best of both’. It isn’t, IMHO.
It's not like picking EDC on an M3.
There are two systems offered on the 5 Series – Variable Damper Control and Adaptive Drive.
Variable Damper Control is an Adaptive setup based on the SE suspension. It has 20mm higher ride height than an M Sport car and a VDC fitted car in Sport mode does not offer equivalent ride and handling to a passive M Sport suspension fitted car. Think of it is a comfortable suspension that can be made a bit firmer, not a ‘sporty’ suspension that can be made more comfortable. A car fitted with just VDC does not handle as well as a car fitted with passive M Sport suspension and exhibits more body roll etc.
Adaptive Drive adds Dynamic Drive to the Variable Damper Control which gives the cars electronically controlled hydraulic anti rollbars as well as the adaptive dampers. This system is excellent and absolutely does offer the best of all worlds – great handling but with the option of more comfort when needed.
So, the magazines go on and on and on about how adaptive suspension is ‘essential’ on the F10 yet 9/10 they are reviewing the 520d – a car for which Adaptive Drive was never offered and the only choice available was VDC which IMHO is an inferior setup to a passive M Sport car. The passive M Sport setup already offers a good compromise between ride and handling. You cannot get more comfort without either compromising the cars handling or going for the full on Adaptive Drive system which is very rare on a used car. A lot of people make the assumption that VDC alone is a ‘best of both’. It isn’t, IMHO.
It's not like picking EDC on an M3.