My thoughts...
Fired this up for the first time since becoming a junior member way back when....
I LOVE IT.
Go Karts with 37 other AI drivers around Donnington, felt great, even with a pad.
Dare I say it reminds me of the original TOCA BTCC games from many moons ago, a sim/arcade hybrid if you will?
I love the idea of hardcore "sim" racing, I love being at the mercy of real world physics, tyre marbling, dry racing lines, laser scanned tracks etc etc.
The problem for me, is that this does not always lend well to a "gaming" experience.
Also, most of these experiences only "work" with a wheel/pedal setup and personally, even though I have wheel stand pro for my G25, it is still a chore to set it up and even when setup, there is compromise on the seating, pedal position etc as you can only really get that right if you have a dedicated racing chassis.
So, you are ready to race your uber realistic sim racing "game" with your compromised seating position, fancy stand and lets be honest, even spending £200+ gets you a bottom of the pile wheel/pedals combo for those who are serious.
You then find out that after all that, it just does not feel "right".
Sometimes I just want to run a pickup race, with a gamepad (Yes sim fans, a gamepad "shock horror").
The problem here is that only a few of these titles can be played with a gamepad.
Sure, there are MANY titles which fully support gamepads but they insult our intelligence with their stupid handling and physics.
What is wrong with wanting to use a gamepad yet not be insulted with a diluted racing experience.
Project Cars on a personal level is a raucous Sim/Arcade hybrid and gets the basics right (from the pre-release I have played thus far) yet has depth missing from the majority of titles, and yes, can be played VERY well with a gamepad which is not surprising seeing as the PC release is being shared with consoles.
Another point I would like to touch on is mods.
I love the openness of the PC platform although games which allow modding are not always the better off for it.
I have no objection to paying for a game and having a good selection of cars and tracks to master with no wiff of modding if the stock content is upto standard.
Will I miss a potential library of thousands of mods of which I will try to download all and play for 3 laps and go "nice" then not touch again. Sure, you will get the odd "killer" mod but with enough stock content, is this really a problem? Not for me.
Project Cars, I salute you. You may well be able to fill a space in my gaming heart which has been empty for a LONG time.