So whats the verdict? Is an instant classic? should I be slapped for not preordering it or buying it on day of release?
I've now played about 150 turns, so I can give a short comment. To start with, the stuff I'm not sold on...
The game seems a lot slower, but it also plays a lot...easier? The game itself is not easier, but the UI seems a lot slicker and basically makes it easy to know what's happening around you with loads of notifications popping up all the time (squeezing in a good thing here!). Strangely enough, it sometimes feels like it's forgetting units and I'm losing out on moves - might just be in my head though.
I've just switched the game off without saving - I want to start again on a larger map. The maps don't feel very big and the landmasses therefore feel crowded - which obviously leads to more interaction (which is a good thing, I guess) - on my small to medium sized continent I had 4 other civs and 5 city states - plenty to keep me busy - but by the year 1000AD, there was probably a total of significantly less than 20 cities (including the city states). It's certainly a bit lacking in the "epic proportions" department in the game I played.
Diplomacy has good and bad points - I dislike not being able to see what other civs think of me - the only indication I've ever had was the word "hostile" which suddenly appeared on the diplomacy screen at some point. The Trade screen seems a little "washed out"? Not sure if that makes sense or not - possibly just an age thing.
Enough of the negatives/undecideds, on to the positives...
Combat is better. I always did dislike the stack system (especially as it always seemed to be the other guy who had massive stacks
![Big Grin :D :D](/styles/default/xenforo/vbSmilies/Normal/biggrin.gif)
), but still getting to grips with how ranged combat works.
Graphics are functional and pretty, not taxing on my system at all.
I do like the new barbarian system and the City State quest system. Plenty opportunity for reasonably simple diplomacy.
I also like the new interface - yes, it has a consoley feel to it due to the size of the icons, but to be perfectly honest, I often found things in Civ4 too small. Maybe it's age and eyesight, but it's functional and fits into the game just fine.
Economy-wise, they have dumbed it down - but I was never the best micro-manager anyway. The basics are still there and your choices on buildings and improvements still have a marked effect on your civ - you just don't need to be staring at the city screens for ages to try and maximise your outputs.
I like the new society improvements so far - you can get some pretty cool bonuses, depening on how you want to play. I'm pleased religion is gone from the game.
All in all, it has promise. I'll probably be playing all day and see how it goes - my opinion may change after a few hours.