Loved Doom 1 and 2 when I was younger, fantastic games for their time, but Doom 3 to me was a much better game, loved the atmosphere but totally understand the “not really Doom” comments. But it just felt like that it had to go that way to stay relevant with other FPS games coming out at the time
Didn’t really like Doom 4, I enjoyed it sure but found it draining to play for stretches. Had to force myself to complete it. I get that it’s a nod to the Dooms of old, but it just felt too arcadey to me and gaming has moved on since the original Doom games so that play style just didn’t suit me