Denilson and Walcott I agree with. Terrible game for both of them. Song, again, put in a very solid performance. Rosicky had a good game as well. The problem was Arsenal lacked the killer instinct in the final third. Arshavin had 3 good opportunities that he ballsed up and with a decent striker in there it would have been a different game.
Players miss chances, thats simply life, its the complete isolation of Arshavin that means the way he plays lately is always in a crowd, always under immense pressure, normally receiving the ball with back to goal with no support. Thats how he played today, someone with his head down focusing on the defenders and not his support. Thats happening because of our formation and the way we play football, NOT because Arshavin isn't good enough.
Considering you've picked the one player basically in history who managed to score 4 goals with 4 shots, well, Arshavin wasn't our problem, it was the fundamental issue of the way we play in that formation. 4-5-1/4-3-3 with two defensive midfielders will always leave us short.
There has been game, after game, after game, where we can't make a break through and it takes Gallas/Vermaelen to venture forwards as that extra midfield runner that Song/Denilson don't provide at all. Unfortunately, as today, that costs us, but I don't remotely blame Gallas, the covering when he went forward was pathetic, and if our midfield played the ball better, faster and supported better then he wouldn't have needed to get forwards. At least he showed some hunger and urgency.
As for Song having a good game, what he did against Rooney summed him up, when racing to get back, he slowed down before he got goal side of Rooney, he got lucky and nicked the ball off him, but then for no godly reason he turned into Rooney, towards our goal and that almost cost us a goal, that was also a piece of play that Utd got the ball because he tried a stupid slide rule pass he's simply not capable of, after he delayed the play, again, when he had quicker and simply options he ignored, again as he did all game.
The amount of times Denilson and Song didn't track midfield runners into the box was laughable, again Song got lucky when he intercepted the ball from Carrick in our 6 yard box, however if you watch the play Carrick just runs right past Song who doesn't react, he's just jogging back as usual ignoring everything around him. Only the fact that the play was slow and the ball across the box took time let Song get back, if it was an early ball it was a tap in for Carrick because Song didn't track the run, again.
He also got a stupid yellow early and repeatedly fouled people and could easily have gone for a 2nd yellow, though that would have been harsh in this game. But on a yellow he didn't stop the stupid shoves and trips from behind he does all game long.
EDIT:_ Clichy has been appaling in these two games, after the utter mauling by Young it was ridiculous to pick him again. Eboue got sent off in the ACN and so wasn't really tired at all, he's not played for a week or so and didn't last the full match
Considering he actually got two decent crosses in, out of 2, and blew past Evra with ease the first time he was given the ball he was better than Sagna or Clichy, no idea why he wouldn't start ahead of CLichy who is clearly not ready to be back yet.