Global BSOD

Associate
Joined
7 Jan 2012
Posts
1,996
Location
Liverpool
Caporegime
Joined
19 May 2004
Posts
32,047
Location
Nordfriesland, Germany
The fact that a software update not from MS can cripple the entire OS from even booting is just really crappy design. I don't care whether this is a server OS or a consumer one it really shouldn't happen. MS needs to make the OS far more resilient to this in the future.

Drivers for every operating system can do this. MS gives greater liberty to services like CrowdStrike - and that should be looked at - but every OS has vulnerabilities.
 
Man of Honour
Joined
13 Oct 2006
Posts
91,894
One of the things I liked about RISC OS - could always boot unstrapped from the ROM if the software environment got stuffed up in some way. Albeit that is more complicated when you have a larger range of possible base hardware configurations and require 3rd party drivers, etc.

What I do think this demonstrates is how pants on head stupid MS's (and other parties) approach to updates and automatic updates, especially forced, is, even in corporate environments which roll out stable tested images on more critical systems.
 
Last edited:
Soldato
Joined
7 Nov 2002
Posts
7,514
Location
pantyhose factory
Question is why? Why this specific update? Or is it "common" practise to push updates bypassing QA testing? Again, why? Either way, a colossal boo boo.
I've spoken to ex-colleagues today and it has, as expected, been an utter nightmare alongside bitlocker'd end-points. Never been so glad to be retired!

e: gibberish on first line.

its only common practice for companies running waffer thin IT departments. I work in Pharma and my compnay was totally unaffected because we don't just blindly accept all security updaters. All updates get rinsed in snadbox first using clones of our production encironments ebfore anyone even thinks about signing off approvals to push to production. the reaosn its such a big problem is becuase of a combination of greed and laziness. A lot of big corporations don't bother even sandboxing windows updates and jsut let them get auto pushed to live environments for the sole reason that its cheap and easy. Why pay for someone to look at testing something that comes from a big multinational conglomorate ?????
 
Soldato
Joined
18 Oct 2002
Posts
8,162
Location
The Land of Roundabouts
its only common practice for companies running waffer thin IT departments. I work in Pharma and my compnay was totally unaffected because we don't just blindly accept all security updaters. All updates get rinsed in snadbox first using clones of our production encironments ebfore anyone even thinks about signing off approvals to push to production. the reaosn its such a big problem is becuase of a combination of greed and laziness. A lot of big corporations don't bother even sandboxing windows updates and jsut let them get auto pushed to live environments for the sole reason that its cheap and easy. Why pay for someone to look at testing something that comes from a big multinational conglomorate ?????

Im intrigued, your essentially saying your company tests every av definition update? bearing in mind these get released at least once a day with more on occasion? not many company's have that sort of ability (they may well invest in more now after this) and your very much in the minority if you are testing such updates.

One thing for sure is a lot of company's BCP's are going to be getting a refresh! we were not even hit but we will be adding a recovery plan for such an incident going forward. it might just involve shipping a usb stick with a windows installation on and letting autopilot do the rest but this incident has opened the eyes of a lot of organisations no doubt.
 
Last edited:
Soldato
Joined
26 May 2009
Posts
22,106
Correction.
It doesn't say which specific hospital had the issue just "A UK hospital" however I would bet money it's in England :p

Also, one hospital is a lot more than I would have expected to have issues with their Varian kit over this considering Varian's upgrade cycle speed (they're currently still working on transitioning their kit from Windows 7 to 10, no joke).
 
Caporegime
Joined
29 Jan 2008
Posts
58,934
Drivers for every operating system can do this. MS gives greater liberty to services like CrowdStrike - and that should be looked at - but every OS has vulnerabilities.

While this is true and indeed Mac has had some issues with previous OS releases and stuff like Adobe software has caused some crashes before it doesn't have the BSOD thing Windows has.

If a MacBook crashes and someone is trying to access a GP appointment system or whatever then just restart it. More rarely they have kernel panic but again... reboot. The BSOD thing here required people to know to reboot in safe mode, delete a system file etc.. and often they don't have access to that or need to faff around and wait for IT end result GP receptionists, train people etc.. all basically locked out of their windows machines until IT sorts it.
 
Back
Top Bottom