You are probably correct
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fc608/fc608ab6e6dc2469165c10f9a8cb020731d10c69" alt="Smile :) :)"
From my own experience over various card generations, my 780 Classified ASIC reading is by far the highest I have encountered.
Now this may be total coincidence, but this is the first time I have purchased a top end, i.e non reference card.
Whilst I tend to agree, based upon the little research I have carried out, that the ASIC value is meaningless, there has to be some science behind it.
Whether a "binned" chip automatically guarantees a high ASIC I have no idea.
Ironically, a lower ASIC value is supposedly better for water/LN2 which is what I would imagine a large proportion of the "real overclockers" are using to cool their cards