No, he isn't right.
Have you not seen his extremely odd thread and post history up to this point? They have been linked to in this thread a few times.
I mean some of his posts in this thread alone just scream obvious trolling, but you seem to have missed them.
I know there is a very slim outside chance he could be telling the truth, but common sense would suggest he's lying.
Give everything a read again and come back to planet earth.
Everything you say above is nebulous.
Not everyone is like that, but too often threads descend into "Let's pick part the OP as much as we can" - even if they have just asked a reasonable question or posted something they thought others might be interested in.
It has got to a point where before posting a thread you have to make sure you've added in disclaimers to cover your back.
I like GD, but there are too many keyboard heroes and experts. Either that or it is the same 10-20 members.
Indeed, Forde.