I was a huge WoW fan during vanilla and TBC and a bit during WOTLK
My guild was the top raiding guild on the server, cleared to 4HM in Naxx, cleared all content on TBC pre nerf etc etc
I have recently returned to play vanilla on a private server and i am absolutely loving it, i raid once per week (sunday night), we are currently farming BWL in prep for AQ release in the coming 2months. will prob raid twice per week once its released
The commitment to retail vanilla is not nearly the same, i raided 5 timers per wk back then, no way could i do that now
even if u dont want to raid id still recommend it, the server has a pop of up too 9k at any given time, meaning lvling characters is extremely fun as there r always groups for anything u want to do
Ohh yes and i play is @ 1440p on a 34 inch super-wide screen, great for immersion
in my time since retail vanilla i have yet to find anygame that can hold my attention for long (apart from Med total war 2) so i bit the bullet and rerolled my tank once i heard this server was being released... i like urself have always looked for something similar but nothing has ever come close
and they have recently released a 2nd server (pve) approx 1 month ago
If u enjoyed it back then ull enjoy it again now