I've been trolling on POF this past week. I messaged mostly HB6+ girls but I've learned when it comes to online dating, you can automatically add 2 points to any girls hotness rating.
I picked something out of their profile or photos and sent stupid (attempted humour) messages to about 30 girls in the 24-31 age range (I'm 30). I got a few replies - some of the smart ones said they laughed, some of the thick ones didn't get it. For example, in one profile this girl put this in her profile (after I roll my eyes at her use of "random"):
I have an occasional flare for trying new random things.
So I sent:
"I too have an occasional flare but only when signalling ships at sea."
She didn't get it. She was an HB6.
Naturally most girls just didn't reply. I've had far more success from cold approaches in the shops or on the train. I get phones numbers from HB5 and HB6 on every other attempt but with online dating, even the average looking ones won't even speak to you. I messaged a few munters and they all replied.
Holy shizzle, that's just cringe worthy. You kinda sound like the male equivalent of them tango'd blondes wearing ugg boots and non-prescription glasses. You know, a small minority, but enough to bring societies opinion of the whole gender down.
Stop reading american pick-up books, that kind of stuff only works in America. Your messages sound very... forced, trying to be funny when you're not is more of a turn off than not actually being funny.
Here's an idea, no matter what you say on the initial message to someone, they'll either reply or not. Online Dating allows people to be more than particular about who they wish to date. Being the pick-up master you sound like, you should know this. Women (and men) look for certain things in a partner, social status, wealth, security, excitement, looks etc. Now, if you're not getting replies then you either haven't demonstrated on your profile that you have all of those qualities that person is looking for, or more than likely you don't actually have them.
So what can you do?! Yes, you could try and come up with some more awesomely funny opening messages in the hope one catches them unawares! Or, you could work to improve the said qualities above, and look to better yourself, and in the process maybe just maybe you'll meet someone with the same mind-set.