SadlAnd the word is instead of punishing individuals, punish everyone.
thats a very tricky one, how do we punish individuals ? I really don't want to start suspending folks for that sort of thing
SadlAnd the word is instead of punishing individuals, punish everyone.
If there was a seperate thread then that would have been locked for being a United thread....
please stop talking sense, it has no place on here
I've just come on here and find it a total **** take that the summer transfer thread has been closed on the basis that it's not a club thread almost like there is a club thread for the discussion that was taking place and the punishable offence was discussing it in the wrong place.
So let me get this right then;
We're not allowed club threads but at the same time we're not allowed to discuss what may merit being in a club thread either.
as long as it was on one topic then it would not
I just don't get what problem you have with it. It creates no problem as far as I can tell. Locking it creates a problem as it stifles discussion and annoys people.
thats a very tricky one, how do we punish individuals ? I really don't want to start suspending folks for that sort of thing
I disagree. .
we know
Well that's the thing, if derailing threads is such an issue then should:
A - The thread be locked, no-one gets to discuss it, discussion is halted (making the forum pointless)
or
B - The repeat offenders, people that take threads off topic with the same bile week in, week out. I won't name names but it should be pretty clear who was doing it tonight and every other time. They get infractions/warnings/3 day suspensions until they stop doing it?
Scenario A is clearly not the right answer unless you want to stifle all discussion.
so supporters of other clubs or people looking for transfer information should have to wade through 90% of the thread being unrelated to the topic ?
Poor performance from Everton last night.
so supporters of other clubs or people looking for transfer information should have to wade through 90% of the thread being unrelated to the topic ?
so supporters of other clubs or people looking for transfer information should have to wade through 90% of the thread being unrelated to the topic ?
that makes little sense, can you try and explain your point a bit better as that is just confusing
I can see your point but then we get bitched at for being heavy handed with warnings/suspensions
Barely qualified as a performancePoor performance from Everton last night.
so supporters of other clubs or people looking for transfer information should have to wade through 90% of the thread being unrelated to the topic ?