Lost Season 5 (Sunday, Sky1, 9PM)

[hamesy]

The blackrock is how the dharma initiative found the island in the first place. It was either a compass or a map from the blackrock was found and sold at auction. It was in season 2 iirc

No. The Dharma was on there before the captain diary was sold at auction, as Widmore was the person who won the auction. Desmond walked into the auction room to see Widmore shortly afterwards.

EDIT: Actually, it was a ledger and was found by pirates in 1852. It eventually got in the hands of Hanso until it was sold in the auction.

 

[wormwood]

No, because young Whidmore was about the same age as the blonde woman on the island, and Charlotte and Whidmore are nowhere near the same age in what we understand to be the present. Could be her mother though?

I assumed the girl was his mother? I'm sure something indicated to that. As for Charlotte it appears she has been on the island before, probably as a child which is why she is bleeding so soon. The guy who senses dead people might be the Dharma initiative guy on the videos son as we see he has a child.

 

[Belmit]

I assumed the girl was his mother?

Could be, but if it is it's a bit of a plot hole. I'm pretty sure I'd recognise my own mother regardless of how old she was!

 

[wormwood]

Could be, but if it is it's a bit of a plot hole. I'm pretty sure I'd recognise my own mother regardless of how old she was!

Well he does say she looks very familar to someone he used to know. I got the impression he knew who she was. The names were wrong though and now I think about it his mother didn't look 70 in that bed. Hair, features and colouring looked spot on though.

 

[DarkShadow]

Id be happier if they did a heroes cross-over arc and brought Claire from Heroes over to meet Lost Claire and.......


Sorry where was I?

My dawg zibit says summin like this . .

I'll put a Claire in yo Claire so you get lost while you get lost

 

[Barks]

Has the latest one come out on Sky yet wouldn't mind sharing a few thoughts. A LOT is revealed in that episode

 

[Shamikebab]

Yes quite an episode!! (not sure if it's been on Sky yet, Saturday isn't it normally?)

 

[Psypher5]

sunday... 9pm.

can we have an early bird thread?

 

[Barks]

thoughts?

 

[Hostile_18]

Well he does say she looks very familar to someone he used to know. I got the impression he knew who she was. The names were wrong though and now I think about it his mother didn't look 70 in that bed. Hair, features and colouring looked spot on though.

The lady in the bed was not his mother. His mothers the women whos sending them back to the island.

Anyways just to clarify The Women holding a gun to Daniel in "Jughead" was indeed Daniels mother. Richard called her "Ella"; the women who is getting them back to the island is called "Eloise Hawking" notice a similarity?

 

[Psypher5]

Anyways just to clarify The Women holding a gun to Daniel in "Jughead" was indeed Daniels mother. Richard called her "Ella"; the women who is getting them back to the island is called "Eloise Hawking" notice a similarity?

you cant be sure though It is lost after all.

 

[Hostile_18]

you cant be sure though It is lost after all.

True but shes also one of the only people that knows how to get back to the island, most likely because she left there once before. If its wrong then its an intentinal mis-direction.

 

[Psypher5]

yup, i do agree on the theory (me and my mate both said it as we were watching it) it seems logical but... is it "supposed" to be logical or are they forcing it

I like the anagram on the van that locke is in

 

[Simian]

The guy who senses dead people might be the Dharma initiative guy on the videos son as we see he has a child.

I had this EXACT Though!!.. When I watched the opening shots of the first episode and saw the Baby... it was then pushed out of my head when we saw Daniel in the Orchid as it was being constructed back in the 70's... but then the thought came back to me when the first Short Bickering Remarks between Sawyer and him happened!...

At least I'm not the only one who thinks it!.

 

[2StepSteve]

I cannot believe this POS is still on our TV which we pay a premium for. When the writers went on a strike last year they should have called it a day then and there, I know that I could write a better story without it being painfully stretched over 5 seasons. The story has gone from being very interesting to totally ridiculous drawn out tosh.

Also what is with the usage of the string section in the music every 10 seconds to try and build a climax? The whole way this series has been going on just makes me feel ill.. poorly thought out and terribly written and directed. This show brings shame to american shows, there are far better out there to watch than this crap.

 

[titchard]

I cannot believe this POS is still on our TV which we pay a premium for. When the writers went on a strike last year they should have called it a day then and there, I know that I could write a better story without it being painfully stretched over 5 seasons. The story has gone from being very interesting to totally ridiculous drawn out tosh.

Also what is with the usage of the string section in the music every 10 seconds to try and build a climax? The whole way this series has been going on just makes me feel ill.. poorly thought out and terribly written and directed. This show brings shame to american shows, there are far better out there to watch than this crap.

Then don't watch it. Or post in a fan thread. Quit trolling.

Rich

 

[Simian]

I cannot believe this POS is still on our TV which we pay a premium for. When the writers went on a strike last year they should have called it a day then and there, I know that I could write a better story without it being painfully stretched over 5 seasons. The story has gone from being very interesting to totally ridiculous drawn out tosh.

Also what is with the usage of the string section in the music every 10 seconds to try and build a climax? The whole way this series has been going on just makes me feel ill.. poorly thought out and terribly written and directed. This show brings shame to american shows, there are far better out there to watch than this crap.

Then don't watch it. Or post in a fan thread. Quit trolling.

Rich

Yeah.. take a look at the top of your TV remote!.. there's usually a really usefull button up there marked 'Power' or something!!.. Just press that and you problem will be solved!!... either that or go and watch 'Dancing on Ice' or some other Fantastic UK produced TV program that you say is sooo much better than Lost!!..

If you don't like it!!. Don't watch it!!..

 

[hamesy]

I cannot believe this POS is still on our TV which we pay a premium for. When the writers went on a strike last year they should have called it a day then and there, I know that I could write a better story without it being painfully stretched over 5 seasons. The story has gone from being very interesting to totally ridiculous drawn out tosh.

Also what is with the usage of the string section in the music every 10 seconds to try and build a climax? The whole way this series has been going on just makes me feel ill.. poorly thought out and terribly written and directed. This show brings shame to american shows, there are far better out there to watch than this crap.

No one is forcing you to watch it.

 

[Belmit]

I cannot believe this POS is still on our TV which we pay a premium for. When the writers went on a strike last year they should have called it a day then and there, I know that I could write a better story without it being painfully stretched over 5 seasons. The story has gone from being very interesting to totally ridiculous drawn out tosh.

This makes no sense to me. If anything, it was series 2 and 3 that stretched on and on with constant (mostly useless) back story and no story progression. Hitting the thing on the head at the time of the writers strike would have left the whole thing unexplained, or explained in so trite a way as to be practically flicking the V's at the avid viewer... especially when you take into account that they already knew where they wanted to get to by the end and, admittedly, were just squeezing what they could out of the earlier series.

Only now are we finally seeing some proper applied science fiction theory as opposed to a constant stream of episodes concentrating on the history behind a single character's decision-making processes that affect one banal choice in the present.

 

[Barks]

I cannot believe this POS is still on our TV which we pay a premium for. When the writers went on a strike last year they should have called it a day then and there, I know that I could write a better story without it being painfully stretched over 5 seasons. The story has gone from being very interesting to totally ridiculous drawn out tosh.

Also what is with the usage of the string section in the music every 10 seconds to try and build a climax? The whole way this series has been going on just makes me feel ill.. poorly thought out and terribly written and directed. This show brings shame to american shows, there are far better out there to watch than this crap.

Wicked mate.