My Photos.. critique and feedback very welcome!

The OP has typical 'My First DSLR' shots, we've all been there. Sorry :p Some nice stuff on your flickr though.
 
Last edited:
You are good at this, already have composition and processing way ahead of someone who only been shooting for 6 months.
 
Janesy B said:
Typical 'My First DSLR' shots, we've all been there. Sorry :p
Click to expand...

I don't know why you bother to post if you have nothing useful or constructive to add..

* Oh, you edited your comment, why?

Raymond Lin said:
You are good at this, already have composition and processing way ahead of someone who only been shooting for 6 months.
Click to expand...

Thank you Raymond, I can definitely see progress when comparing my latest photos to the ones when I first started.
 
Last edited:
JBuk said:
Or maybe he has a point that you should consider rather than dismissing it because it's not positive.
Click to expand...

I didn't dismiss it, did I? Like you, he had nothing useful or constructive to add and I questioned him about it..

Why did you take the trouble to post? Just to echo him? That's very nice of you, but I think he had it covered without your heroic contribution.
 
keenan said:
I didn't dismiss it, did I? Like you, he had nothing useful or constructive to add and I questioned him about it..

Why did you take the trouble to post? Just to echo him? That's very nice of you, but I think he had it covered without your heroic contribution.
Click to expand...

I took the trouble to post because your shots do look like the typical first slr shots and rather than take it on board and think about maybe why that is, you're getting defensive about it.

Tbh there's too many too critique individually but overall I find most to be decent enough technically but lack any interest to me, there's nothing drawing me in


Ps your thread title does say critique and feedback very welcome
 
Last edited:
JBuk said:
Ps your thread title does say critique and feedback very welcome
Click to expand...

Indeed it does, which means I am looking for critique about my photos.

If you know what critique means, than you know that neither of you actually offered any. That is the problem!

Back on topic, thank you for the constructive input in your last comment, that is something I can take on board..

Janesy B said:
I edited it because I realised it would prompt a response like the above ;)
Click to expand...

Seems quite natural that it did the very exact thing then.. ;)
 
Last edited:
Look like typical new to DSLR type shots at the start tbh...

...but you have improved a lot and certainly have an eye for composition :)

The child flash ones don't work with the black background imo, it doesn't suit the pose / look. The heavily processed BW is really good however, stand out image for me as is 'the view' shot, really nice.

fyi you asked for feedback as well as critique, someone saying your images are s*** would be perfectly valid feedback although harsh.
 
I like these, there much better than your average beginner shots.
I would like to see "the view" in a b&w version it would make a cracking print.
Keep it up your making good progress.
 
Hi again everyone.

Seeing as it's been more than 4 years since my last post in this thread I thought it best if I posted something light hearted on my first re-entry.

Danbo seems like the perfect denominator..
















 
Last edited:
There's a massive jump in the "professionalism" of the photos. It doesn't look like you're gunning for extreme bokeh just because DSLR etc, you're using it to great effect. The 4th one in particular is really really nice - looks like you've turned RTX on :P
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom