Considering other countries have had the same issues and have come out better than we have, I would suggest that a vast majority of the issue is with THIS GOVERNMENT.
National insurance cut
- Thread starter aspiring
- Start date
Considering other countries have had the same issues and have come out better than we have, I would suggest that a vast majority of the issue is with THIS GOVERNMENT.
You could be right of course, I was just pointing out that there are other factors aswell
So you wouldn't blame it on the Soviet Unions invasion as a factor? Or any other external problem that we had no control over that impacted our economy?
Last edited:
So you're no expert but apparently you're expert enough to know it's impossible to pick apart the statistics to remove macro events like that.
Are you a Schrodinger expert?
Soldato
All wars are caused by governments… it’s not like a villager stole another’s bucket and it quickly escalated.
If the governments of different countries didn’t offer Ukraine money for disarming their nukes.. do you think Russia would have the nerve to invade?
If the governments of different countries didn’t offer Ukraine money for disarming their nukes.. do you think Russia would have the nerve to invade?
That has nothing to do with the question about solely our government which most of this is about
You don't need to be an expert to know that, just common sense and life experience.
Last edited:
Argument from incredulity - Wikipedia
Soldato
Sorry no comment
Due you really think it would do any good?
Last edited:
Soldato
Can I remind everyone that on 7 September 2021, Then PM BJ announced the introduction of a Health and Social Care Tax.
By increasing NI by 1.25% (13.25% total) rom 6 April 2022 and for a separate tax to start in April 2023 to tax people a futher 1.25% to address the funding crisis in the sector.
This broke the tory manifesto of not raising taxes, but BJ insists that it was required. "we cannot shirk the challenge of putting the NHS back on its feet"
manifesto: https://www.conservatives.com/our-plan/economy
back bench anger: https://www.theguardian.com/politic...d-tory-anger-over-manifesto-breaking-tax-rise
Then backbencher Hunt said "social care does not actually get as much money as it needs."
7 months later; November 2022, This was reversed by Kami Kwarteng stating, "Taxing our way to prosperity has never worked"
in November 2023, now Chancellor Hunt in the "Autumn Statement for growth" announced a 2p cut to NI in January 2024.
The uk entered a recession late 2023 before the NI cuts took place.
Now two days ago, during the spring budget, Chancellor Hunt cuts NI by 2% again...
So in the space of less than 2 and a half years... the same party that was predicting gloom and doom for the future of our health service unless we start to pay an extra 3%+ now thinks that we can pay 4% less and it will be fine.
Please tick all that applies...
[ ] they have found a magic money tree
[ ] they make **** up as they go along
[ ] they don't care about the billions of people that need the NHS nor the future of social care
[ ] it's an election year
[ ] they are salting the battlefield before losing the war.
[ ] other, please explain:
By increasing NI by 1.25% (13.25% total) rom 6 April 2022 and for a separate tax to start in April 2023 to tax people a futher 1.25% to address the funding crisis in the sector.
This broke the tory manifesto of not raising taxes, but BJ insists that it was required. "we cannot shirk the challenge of putting the NHS back on its feet"
manifesto: https://www.conservatives.com/our-plan/economy
back bench anger: https://www.theguardian.com/politic...d-tory-anger-over-manifesto-breaking-tax-rise
Then backbencher Hunt said "social care does not actually get as much money as it needs."
Social care won't get money it needs, warns Jeremy Hunt
The Conservative former health secretary tells MPs there is a risk the NHS will "gobble up" all the funds.
www.bbc.co.uk
7 months later; November 2022, This was reversed by Kami Kwarteng stating, "Taxing our way to prosperity has never worked"
National Insurance rise to be reversed in November
The 1.25% rise will be reversed from 6 November and a levy to fund health and social care will be axed.
www.bbc.co.uk
in November 2023, now Chancellor Hunt in the "Autumn Statement for growth" announced a 2p cut to NI in January 2024.
The uk entered a recession late 2023 before the NI cuts took place.
What is a recession and how could one affect me?
A recession means the UK economy has shrunk for two three-month periods - or quarters - in a row.
www.bbc.co.uk
Now two days ago, during the spring budget, Chancellor Hunt cuts NI by 2% again...
Budget 2024: Jeremy Hunt cuts National Insurance again as election looms
But Labour says many people will still be worse off because of existing freezes to income tax bands.
www.bbc.co.uk
So in the space of less than 2 and a half years... the same party that was predicting gloom and doom for the future of our health service unless we start to pay an extra 3%+ now thinks that we can pay 4% less and it will be fine.
Please tick all that applies...
[ ] they have found a magic money tree
[ ] they make **** up as they go along
[ ] they don't care about the billions of people that need the NHS nor the future of social care
[ ] it's an election year
[ ] they are salting the battlefield before losing the war.
[ ] other, please explain:
Ok, I'll go with the simple tick box way of doing it.Can I remind everyone that on 7 September 2021, Then PM BJ announced the introduction of a Health and Social Care Tax.
By increasing NI by 1.25% (13.25% total) rom 6 April 2022 and for a separate tax to start in April 2023 to tax people a futher 1.25% to address the funding crisis in the sector.
This broke the tory manifesto of not raising taxes, but BJ insists that it was required. "we cannot shirk the challenge of putting the NHS back on its feet"
manifesto: https://www.conservatives.com/our-plan/economy
back bench anger: https://www.theguardian.com/politic...d-tory-anger-over-manifesto-breaking-tax-rise
Then backbencher Hunt said "social care does not actually get as much money as it needs."
Social care won't get money it needs, warns Jeremy Hunt
The Conservative former health secretary tells MPs there is a risk the NHS will "gobble up" all the funds.www.bbc.co.uk
7 months later; November 2022, This was reversed by Kami Kwarteng stating, "Taxing our way to prosperity has never worked"
National Insurance rise to be reversed in November
The 1.25% rise will be reversed from 6 November and a levy to fund health and social care will be axed.www.bbc.co.uk
in November 2023, now Chancellor Hunt in the "Autumn Statement for growth" announced a 2p cut to NI in January 2024.
The uk entered a recession late 2023 before the NI cuts took place.
What is a recession and how could one affect me?
A recession means the UK economy has shrunk for two three-month periods - or quarters - in a row.www.bbc.co.uk
Now two days ago, during the spring budget, Chancellor Hunt cuts NI by 2% again...
Budget 2024: Jeremy Hunt cuts National Insurance again as election looms
But Labour says many people will still be worse off because of existing freezes to income tax bands.www.bbc.co.uk
So in the space of less than 2 and a half years... the same party that was predicting gloom and doom for the future of our health service unless we start to pay an extra 3%+ now thinks that we can pay 4% less and it will be fine.
Please tick all that applies...
[ ] they have found a magic money tree
[ ] they make **** up as they go along
[ ] they don't care about the billions of people that need the NHS nor the future of social care
[ ] it's an election year
[ ] they are salting the battlefield before losing the war.
[ ] other, please explain:
Be it on your own head though.
I would tick..............
Soldato
They should never have put it up in the first place it was a dumb thing to do then, and the right thing to do to reverse that and now cut it further.
Think about it Dan
Soldato
I have thanks. I was against the new health and social care tax rise in 2021.
Remember the other forum ?
Soldato
Sorry you've lost me.
Rigged replies you have to tick the box to all the questions, would be my take on it
Last edited:
Soldato
How would you fund the black hole in health and social care?
Soldato
If you look at what you have asked us to do and the current feeling of the country I would answer by ticking every single box and I would assume most here would