The only accurate statement in this THREAD is
"We don't the know the details"
We don't know the price of the GPUs from either AMD or NVidia.
We don't know the performance of the GPUs from either AMD or Nvidia.
We don't know what the power consumption will be, we certainly can't base it off any information from the PS5.
And you certainly can't guarantee any of the things you said.
oh, Just Vega and Fury to poke fun at? What about Tahiti? Hawaii? Polaris? None of those launches went very well at all. AMD can't have another bad launch.
So true, so very true.
Oh yes and I fixed that for you.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c52ff/c52ff17eea75f5fa374792d68c3cb4c06c406d96" alt="Wink ;) ;)"
More seriously, you are quite right AMD has to get this one right, they cannot afford another **** up like they keep seeming to do. Of course in the same breath NVidia has to have a smooth launch with no space invaders or leaf blower coolers. So I do hope that this aparent new push pull cooler design works well, even though it still looks like the V shaped fins block airflow.