Soldato
Would just like to say we have until tomorrow
Edit: My thoughts echo Shamie's almost exactly.
Last edited:
OcUK Mafia game thread - Game 3
- Thread starter iviv
- Start date
Would just like to say we have until tomorrow
Edit: My thoughts echo Shamie's almost exactly.
I'm going to
vote: Fortyseven
In hindsight we should have done that ahead of Jedi.
I'm assuming the cop has been bumped off with the lack of any concrete theories we have to go on. If the cop is still out there it would be worth putting forward some good but subtle arguments as to who to vote for as we are starting to run out of time to root out the mafia
vote: Fortyseven
In hindsight we should have done that ahead of Jedi.
I'm assuming the cop has been bumped off with the lack of any concrete theories we have to go on. If the cop is still out there it would be worth putting forward some good but subtle arguments as to who to vote for as we are starting to run out of time to root out the mafia
Caporegime
Yeah I assume the cop is dead, no-one is really standing out. I have a feeling it might have been Kaiowas.
Soldato
I was going to mention the cop in my long post above, but forgot to do so. I think the mafia got lucky and he went very early. Kaiowas was my guess too.
So do I take my own advice and vote Fortyseven for the good of the town. Or go with my 2nd theory that Brabbinho could be mafia and now is the best time to off Fortyseven as he's another Townie and he's served his purpose?
So do I take my own advice and vote Fortyseven for the good of the town. Or go with my 2nd theory that Brabbinho could be mafia and now is the best time to off Fortyseven as he's another Townie and he's served his purpose?
Soldato
We need all perspectives tbh. Let's hear them.
Caporegime
It would be hilarious if fortyseven was the cop, It's hard enough working out whether to believe him as it is 
Soldato
Yet nobody mentions me! 
I'm suspicious of Ghost merely by his absence and it this point I'm fairly certain FortySeven isn't mafia unless he really is a super genius.
My top 3 right now are Ghost, Gooner and Shami but my reasoning isn't exactly very sound. I said I'd go back and re-read it some more but actually today all I did was be hungover and play Skyrim :/
Tomorrow hopefully should bring more obvious answers to light!
I'm suspicious of Ghost merely by his absence and it this point I'm fairly certain FortySeven isn't mafia unless he really is a super genius.
My top 3 right now are Ghost, Gooner and Shami but my reasoning isn't exactly very sound. I said I'd go back and re-read it some more but actually today all I did was be hungover and play Skyrim :/
Tomorrow hopefully should bring more obvious answers to light!
Caporegime
I completely forgot you were still alive! Edited my post above
Soldato
Yet nobody mentions me!
If it makes you feel better, I think you are town, along with Pudney
Soldato
I completely forgot you were still alive! Edited my post above
Hoora.....y /o\
If it makes you feel better, I think you are town, along with Pudney
Damn right I'm town, and proud with it
Soldato
Soldato
But of course! I wouldn't want to tip my hand now would I?
Soldato
I'm thinking the same, Fortyseven is a smoke screen for the other two and no, I am not mafia.
I'll have to read through everything again and decide who to vote for after work. I've had a busy weekend so not really had chance to properly follow the thread in the past two days.
Associate
- Joined
- 26 Jan 2006
- Posts
- 2,039
Ok, here goes, cards on the table time.
I am town and from my persective, that of knowing I am town but having everyone think I am not, I have picked up a few things, they may be way off.
Egon: If he was mafia I think he would be more subtle at pointing the finger at me. The only people other than myself that know exactly what I am are the mafia, so I don't think they would be screaming it from the roof tops in fear of being too obvious. For now, I think he is town.
Pudney: One of the few people who believed that my late vote could be a mistake, has not done anything hugely suspect. Town, but less sure about this.
K1LLSW1TCH: Another that thought that my late vote could just be a stupid mistake. Has been reasonably quiet in his accusations, was quick to jump on killing Jedi, based on Kaiowas' previous game performance, and I feel that this is the same reason that Kaiowas is dead. I think he is town.
Brabbinho: Has more subtly (than Egon) kept eyes on me through out, voted out Jedi when the crowd started going that way and openly stating that I would be next to hang. Then starting casting suspicion towards Pudney, who I am pretty sure is town. He is probably the highest on my list of Mafia suspects.
Shamikebab: His previous post sums up my feelings for most the rest of the group, therefore I think he is most likely town.
Psymonkee: I am not a super genius, so I think he is a supporter of me. The more people that are convinced I am not Mafia, the less useful I am to them so I cannot believe that they would then get people to look elsewhere.
GhostWKD and Gooner: Not much to go on, one of them in sure is Mafia and is playing the quiet game. Maybe offing someone for the reason of being quiet might make them post more...but that might be wasteful.
Right now I'd be looking at Brabbinho, either GhostWKD and Gooner (or both) and the third playing a really good game.
The only thing that is blinding me at the moment is people supporting me, i have no idea why Mafia would want people to leave me alone.
I could be way off, and I know me that saying people are town could make them suspects but as I say, I know I am town and therefore have an extra bit of information the other townies are missing.
EDIT: Either the cop is dead, or has not yet found a Mafia member.
If he is alive, surely by now he would have investigated me, and hasn't come forward to say I am town. (This would be wasteful, revealing yourself as a cop just to save 1 townie.)
I am town and from my persective, that of knowing I am town but having everyone think I am not, I have picked up a few things, they may be way off.
Egon: If he was mafia I think he would be more subtle at pointing the finger at me. The only people other than myself that know exactly what I am are the mafia, so I don't think they would be screaming it from the roof tops in fear of being too obvious. For now, I think he is town.
Pudney: One of the few people who believed that my late vote could be a mistake, has not done anything hugely suspect. Town, but less sure about this.
K1LLSW1TCH: Another that thought that my late vote could just be a stupid mistake. Has been reasonably quiet in his accusations, was quick to jump on killing Jedi, based on Kaiowas' previous game performance, and I feel that this is the same reason that Kaiowas is dead. I think he is town.
Brabbinho: Has more subtly (than Egon) kept eyes on me through out, voted out Jedi when the crowd started going that way and openly stating that I would be next to hang. Then starting casting suspicion towards Pudney, who I am pretty sure is town. He is probably the highest on my list of Mafia suspects.
Shamikebab: His previous post sums up my feelings for most the rest of the group, therefore I think he is most likely town.
Psymonkee: I am not a super genius, so I think he is a supporter of me. The more people that are convinced I am not Mafia, the less useful I am to them so I cannot believe that they would then get people to look elsewhere.
GhostWKD and Gooner: Not much to go on, one of them in sure is Mafia and is playing the quiet game. Maybe offing someone for the reason of being quiet might make them post more...but that might be wasteful.
Right now I'd be looking at Brabbinho, either GhostWKD and Gooner (or both) and the third playing a really good game.
The only thing that is blinding me at the moment is people supporting me, i have no idea why Mafia would want people to leave me alone.
I could be way off, and I know me that saying people are town could make them suspects but as I say, I know I am town and therefore have an extra bit of information the other townies are missing.
EDIT: Either the cop is dead, or has not yet found a Mafia member.
If he is alive, surely by now he would have investigated me, and hasn't come forward to say I am town. (This would be wasteful, revealing yourself as a cop just to save 1 townie.)
Last edited:
Soldato
A few people are starting to suspect the same people Fortyseven. I put forward a similar theory about Brabbinho in post #197, Shamiekebab also said something similar in his summary.
The more I think about it the more I think Brabbinho has been playing this game all along. The first to vote Jedi when attentions were starting to be drawn elsewhere and now quick to vote Fortyseven. All fits in with my initial theory.
I'm going to vote now, we're running out of time. I've changed my stance on Fortyseven, yes we should have lynched him instead of Jedi so we could be sure, that was a mistake, but he's convinced me he's innocent. Lynching him now is the wrong move.
VOTE: Brabbinho
The more I think about it the more I think Brabbinho has been playing this game all along. The first to vote Jedi when attentions were starting to be drawn elsewhere and now quick to vote Fortyseven. All fits in with my initial theory.
I'm going to vote now, we're running out of time. I've changed my stance on Fortyseven, yes we should have lynched him instead of Jedi so we could be sure, that was a mistake, but he's convinced me he's innocent. Lynching him now is the wrong move.
VOTE: Brabbinho
Soldato
Soldato
Associate
- Joined
- 26 Jan 2006
- Posts
- 2,039
VOTE: Brabbinho
He is top of my list, as I stated above.
He is top of my list, as I stated above.