OcUK Mafia game thread - Game 3

Been a bit quiet the past day or two chaps, I'm feeling much better now though so I'll read through yesterday's posts and make a decision later on. Early thoughts are that I'm not really 100% sure who to go for yet, Brabbinho looks slightly suspicious today, GhostWKD hasn't been active at all which might make me vote for him just to get him out of the game. Nobody else is really jumping out at me, I never thought Fortyseven was mafia aligned even when he was being accused by a number of people. That said I did make a mistake in voting for Jedi but then we pretty much all did, and he did no favours to himself in the way he conducted his self.
 
Was so sure Brabbinho and Fourtyseven were Mafia until the former voted for the latter (and then vice/versa later on) and now i'm at a loss where to vote. That said I think Brabbinho is more likely to be Mafia than Fourtyseven, Fourtyseven is just playing in a way that would be silly for a Mafia member.

Unfortunately don't think I'll be able to come on again before deadline of voting tonight so my vote's going to go to Brabbinho.

Vote: Brabbinho
 
I'm guilty of not paying 100% to everything that has been said so far but I thought that much of the suspicion toward Fortyseven is based on his day one vote, is that true? If it is then I don't really think that's anything more than grasping at straws.
 
Yes pretty much and I admit that I was quite vocal about lynching him to begin with. However as events have unfolded it would seem that perhaps the Mafia have been using him as a smokescreen. He has now server his purpose and he is ready to be lynched.
 
Egon said:
Not the most convincing counter argument I've ever read :p
Click to expand...

Whether you find it convincing or not it's the truth. I made a massive error of judgement voting for Jedi. Though at the time he's posts weren't overly helping himself.

If you do decide to lynch me tonight, then fair enough. I just hope you pay attention to who voted for me. I would suggest Ghost as mafia. Lack of activity and then posts to jump on the bandwagon to get another townie lynched.

Everything Egon has posted so far makes you think he's townie, but his new support of 47....

The only people I'm confident of being townie are Psy, Shami, killswitch and myself
 
I can't deny I've change my stance... I just think your actions sound more like Mafia to me then Fortyseven.

I think one of you are that way aligned and I think the votes so far reflect that, right now I am more inclined to think it is you.
 
K1LLSW1TCH said:
I'm guilty of not paying 100% to everything that has been said so far but I thought that much of the suspicion toward Fortyseven is based on his day one vote, is that true? If it is then I don't really think that's anything more than grasping at straws.
Click to expand...

Yes this is true but tbh there isn't that much more to go on with Brabbinho, it's basically his part in the Jedi lynching that is suspicious for me.
 
Linking people to me is what got Jedi lynched.

Brabbinho made a good post above, however, he has now accused Pudney and Ego, one of which seemed wild, the other again because of links to me.

I also don't think that losing one more townie will actually result in a Mafia win, whereas Brabbinho is sure that losing him will do so. (And for some reason Psymonkee seems to agree, with no reasoning as to why)

I am now confused however, as GhostWKD has voted Brabbinho, this throws me a little but I am not 100% sure about GhostWKD either way.
 
For me, brabbinho is looking very suspicious. First to vote for lynchings both times, pointed the finger at pretty much everyone else and has a much too nurtured beard.

Pudney keeps pointing the finger at me maybe trying to steer others into voting for me. Shami seems to agree. I don't really have much else to go on but something doesn't add up but at this moment I think they're townies.

But then again, I'm still suspicious of killswitch and egon. I believe egon was saved on the first day by his buddies and again, they jump in to ensure Jedi is lynched as being a veteren player and also voting for egon earlier, meant that he was becoming too dangerous to leave alive and ghost is far too quiet
 
Gooner Leroy said:
For me, brabbinho is looking very suspicious. First to vote for lynchings both times, pointed the finger at pretty much everyone else and has a much too nurtured beard.

Pudney keeps pointing the finger at me maybe trying to steer others into voting for me. Shami seems to agree. I don't really have much else to go on but something doesn't add up but at this moment I think they're townies.

But then again, I'm still suspicious of killswitch and egon. I believe egon was saved on the first day by his buddies and again, they jump in to ensure Jedi is lynched as being a veteren player and also voting for egon earlier, meant that he was becoming too dangerous to leave alive and ghost is far too quiet
Click to expand...

Ok, I'm just about to go to my spreadsheet (I'm really that sad) and decide on my reasoning, before I do though I do want to point one thing out to you :p I've asked once due to you being quiet, my other mentions of you are that I feel guilty to vote for you since the last game where I encouraged a revenge voting!
 
Sorry I thought you mentioned me a couple of times since you didn't agree on the revenge killing. For that I thank you and I'm truly sorry for the injustice you faced.

Tbh I was clutching at straws when suspecting you this game :p

And if it makes you feel any better, I've just made page after page of notes :o
 
If things stay like this (3 votes to 2) then I will switch my vote to Brabbinho, I'm suspicious of both of them but the town seems to be leaning towards Brabbinho and in the end I'm wary of a last minute Mafia vote to ensure no lynching.
 
Are your notes helping? Because my spreadsheet isn't :(

When I first put this together I looked at KILLSW1TCH's actions, he started the lynching of Leprechaun on day 1 and day 2 he started the ball rolling on Jedi 16 minutes after Brabbinho voted (yes, I have times on there). Working in cahoots or just coincidence? Day 3 and he's done nothing suspicious, I was certain if he jumped on a bandwagon again today he was mafia, but now I wonder if I'm just hoping to find reasons.

Fortyseven is the only other one to be involved in both lynchings (day 2 by abstaining, by that time Jedi already had 4 votes and was fairly doomed) but my gut tells me he isn't and my gut is large.
 
Dammit, can't edit posts!

Forgot to say, Brabbinho started game today off pointing the finger at me because of "something" and then happily changed his vote to Fortseven after Shami started the vote. Whilst I don't know what the "something" is I would be more trusting of him if he actually stood by his convictions, his happiness to alter his vote is suspicious. But then I don't want to fall into my "Gooner" ;) trap and vote for him out of revenge!
 
I'm not mafia, but will accept if you guys decide to vote for me as my actions have been a little erratic. I've just really struggled to get to grips with who is mafia this time around.

If I am lynched and when you discover I am a townie I suggest following Gooner's gut
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom