OcUK Mafia game thread -Game 5

Shamikebab said:
Chris is difficult to read, a point to consider is if he does turn out to be mafia then Leprechaun defending him throws him into suspicion to.
Click to expand...

Leprechaun has leapt to my defence. Given that I'm town, there's no reason for mafia to do this
Click to expand...

my intention wasn't really to save chris but more to figure out brabbinhos wierd voting, day one was a valid reason day 2 just seems to be out of the blue
 
Well you're back on my suspicious list then! ;) There's nothing wrong (apart from being wrong!) with casting votes where your suspicions lie. Doesn't look great with people trying to discourage progress in the voting IMO.
 
Votecount so far is
Chriscubed 1 (Brabbinho)
Fortyseven 1 (Chriscubed)

I think we really need some more votes to indicate everyone's current position. It's not like you can't change it if a better option comes up. Once we have some initial votes in we can see who the contenders are and decide on a lynch. 5 hours to go and 2 votes in, come on.
 
Re-read all posts

Leprechaun312 said:
Mateser, day one showed his lust for blood saying that he will be voting no matter what on the final day to secure a lynch, suggesting a random number generator just to get and then jumping on 47 with now real reason other than he agreed with egon. Maybe he being the mafia noticed Egon pushing things along, saw egon pick a townie and jumped on it to try and secure a townie lynch with Egon pushing the way. Now that a townie was lynched he is trying to pose as someone who is pushing the town along when he is not, everything he has said has either been a joke or attempting to secure a lynch.
Click to expand...
That is all I do on the forums though!

Brab, Leprechaun and me are townies. That leaves Shami, FortySeven, Pudney and Chris.

I voted for Forty day one, and I still have suspicions on him. He pointed out that one person who voted him was killed, showing that we should not target him. I think he is a mafia member. That leaves me with one more mafia member to target.
 
Wait, how are you three townies? Speaking in absolutes like that this early on is a little silly.

If I had to vote now I'd probably lead towards Malteser or Brabbinho, their behaviour feels the most suspicious to me.
 
Here is my thoughts atm

Brabb - I think i was wrong in saying he was the tracker, however i'm not sure if he is townie or mafia. His vote is wierd, basically no reasoning behind it and he has voted for chris twice now. The first vote was a valid reason, chris had not posted. His Second vote seems random, like he just wants chris to be lynched. The only valid reason i could think why he would do such a thing was if he was the tracker or he is a townie who doesnt know who to vote so is just picking who he thinks could be mafia. if he was mafia he wouldn't make such a careless vote

Malteser - Stands out to me as a possible mafia. Day one he was trying to secure a lynch at any cost, his support for egon's vote for 47 had no reason literally i agree vote 47. seems rushed. Then day 2 he has self-proclaimed himself as the next mafia target for pushing the town along (which he doesnt) and also self-proclaimed himself as townie. I think he is possibly mafia, though i don't know, but if i get lynched tonight and he lives you know where my suspicions lie.

47 - He is in a sticky setup situation. Either he is mafia and he is playing a very messy game and making it easy for us, maybe thats his plan???? or what i think is the case, he is town and the mafia killed egon to implicate 47. I think he is town and no one trusts him

Shami - Playing the same as he did last game, which stands out to me as town, and i agree with his decisions so i think town.

Now this is where i draw a blank

Chris and pudney i dont really have a reading on either way.

Pudney seems suspicious of me, but tbh is on the fence, doesnt stand out as either town or mafia

Chris ???? idk town or mafia not really a lot to go on. Though he's doing the same thing as last game talking about meta and stuff so i don't know. Though he is one of the people who seems to want 47 dead with no actual reason other than he doesnt like his posts. Atm i think he is town probably though this may change.

Vote Malteser
 
edit: my analysis of brabb is wrong, I think I'm reading too much into his vote. I think he was just trying to get the town talking by voting for chris, which he has achieved. i think brabb is town.
 
I think the post stats are quite interesting:

Leprechaun312 37
The__Malteser 22
chriscubed 18
Shamikebab 18
Brabbinho 16
Pudney 15
Egon 11
Fortyseven 7


Some people are staying very quiet, Fortyseven in particular has posted less than a dead man :p He's done his usual thing of sowing confusion in the town as everyone tries to figure him out!
 
Shamikebab said:
I think the post stats are quite interesting:

Leprechaun312 37
The__Malteser 22
chriscubed 18
Shamikebab 18
Brabbinho 16
Pudney 15
Egon 11
Fortyseven 7


Some people are staying very quiet, Fortyseven in particular has posted less than a dead man :p He's done his usual thing of sowing confusion in the town as everyone tries to figure him out!
Click to expand...

emm.... i post a bit much
 
chriscubed said:
Votecount so far is
Chriscubed 1 (Brabbinho)
Fortyseven 1 (Chriscubed)

I think we really need some more votes to indicate everyone's current position. It's not like you can't change it if a better option comes up. Once we have some initial votes in we can see who the contenders are and decide on a lynch. 5 hours to go and 2 votes in, come on.
Click to expand...

My hesitation in voting is mainly down to my abysmal attempts in the last game.

Leprechaun is the only one who I think has been significantly suspicious, but I also think going from other games I'm just reading too much into it.
 
Right I've had a think and it's time I stop being timid and actually do a vote. My instincts are leaning towards Brabbinho over Malteser. For the reasons I've posted before I'm going to go with that. Wait and see is something I'm too eager to do and it just doesn't work.

Vote Brabbinho
 
To be fair, he was fairly vocal before he died.

If Malteser is Mafia he is playing a very odd game. He is so sure I am Mafia because I pointed out that someone that voted for me got NK'd and that is some kind of double bluff. I think he's town but

I think Brabbinho and chris are town, they seem to be losing the game along well.

That leaves Lep, Shami and Pudney. The issue here is that will a small amount of votes mean that no one has really had to defend themselves so no lines have been drawn.

My vote is going on Shami as he seems to be flip flopping about Brabbinho.

Vote Shamikebab
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom