That thread is just.....lol
Sadly now that TP place is popular, there are some immense tools there. You say something they don't agree with and you can get volumes of abuse, even if it's true and meant in good spirit. Some people will even give you stick when you accidentally post a better photo than theirs was (not that I have anything good anyway, so it wasn't me!) and rip you apart for actually complimenting people and their photo.
Seriously, there's some nut cases in there, especially the theme/competition threads!
Personally I've no idea what Ray does processing wise, and don't care. I like his style, and the photo they're babbling about doesn't look to have frontal lighting to me
I've seen plenty of photos that have that look to them from shooting into the sun, and I've got a couple myself using the Sigma 1.4 wide open, but without flare.
Some people are so worried about competition they insult and accuse in the hope a professional will reveal their techniques pre/post shoot so they can flat out copy it, and looking at their attitudes, undercut.
Incidentally, can anyone access those forums? It seems to have died, and I can't get back on there!
Ah it's loading now. I look forward to reading about how Ray faked the moon landing.