With the state of rubbish Disney put out constantly even they managed to **** this abomination off. Fair play.Apparently this was going to be a Disney star wars project but wasn't good enough
Rebel Moon | Netflix
- Thread starter Glanza
- Start date
-
- Tags
- rebel moon
Soldato
I'm 40 minutes in and I want to kill myself
Soldato
Just watched Part 1 and I didn’t mind it at all despite acting that makes Keanu Reeves look like Sir John Gielgud at the high of his powers.
Clearly, it’s Snyder’s idea of The Seven Samurai/The Hidden Fortress in space with elements of every Sci-Fi franchise from the last 40 years thrown into the stew.
Clearly, it’s Snyder’s idea of The Seven Samurai/The Hidden Fortress in space with elements of every Sci-Fi franchise from the last 40 years thrown into the stew.
Soldato
How does Zack Snyder keep getting work
Soldato
He's a proven great director - when given a lot of supervision and when using someone else's script - yet when he's surrounded by "yes men" who have allowed him to do everything himself without question, he rapidly shows why he needed all the supervision/script work help in the first place!
I really like Snyder's visual style, but this feels like the same problem as when George Lucas was allowed to do the SW Prequel Trilogy without anyone telling him No and with no collaboration/supervision - you end up with the worst of Lucas rather than the best - and thats the trap I think Snyder is in right now, and why I think the best thing for him (which'll never happen) is for him to take a step back and allow others to write, and for him to be forced to collaborate with others over his choices and have them tell him No over stuff, rather than being told "OK" for everything.
I really like Snyder's visual style, but this feels like the same problem as when George Lucas was allowed to do the SW Prequel Trilogy without anyone telling him No and with no collaboration/supervision - you end up with the worst of Lucas rather than the best - and thats the trap I think Snyder is in right now, and why I think the best thing for him (which'll never happen) is for him to take a step back and allow others to write, and for him to be forced to collaborate with others over his choices and have them tell him No over stuff, rather than being told "OK" for everything.
Soldato
I really enjoyed this, an improvement on the first imo. 7/10
Last edited:
Soldato
Same here, I enjoyed both of them.
Caporegime
I must be rare as I preferred the first! Bit too much cheese in 2 for me
Soldato
Part 2 was brain-off fun, especially the final battle where both sides employed the tried and trusted tactical strategy of running directly towards the enemy.
Soldato
Main criticism, too much slow motion farming.
Apparently he wants to do another 4 sequels on top of these 2.
Apparently he wants to do another 4 sequels on top of these 2.
Soldato
the slow mo shots omg some are so bad that they look like someone using pirated Adobe Premiere and playing around with filters but has no clue what they are doing!
Soldato
- Joined
- 25 Sep 2005
- Posts
- 2,880
I quite enjoyed both but they're not movies I would rewatch any time soon.
Soldato
I'm normally all over a big new sci-fi film. These just look so bad though.
Caporegime
Are there any good YouTube film review channels? (Other than ones that are associated with critics/publications outside YouTube).
A little subjective but usually like Jeremy Jawns, Chris Stuckman though haven't watched him for a while and Critical Drinker for some comedy but he loves twisting the knife with his reviews and definitely bandwagons.
Caporegime
I'll have a look, thanks.
Critical Drinker is dreadful. Hasn't a clue about film, and just dribbles culture war crap into the world.