I don't think this is true, or at least, both sides of the argument are opinion and there is not a right way. I'm currently reading a book called 'Move, mount, shoot' by John Bidwell (a former champion). He describes maintained lead as the best method for very many reasons. One is that it utilizes the brains natural ability to calculate the speed and route of the clay put the gun in place keep momentum and shoot. Follow through lends itself to shooting behind, and pull-away makes it very easy to obscure your view of the clay if it drops, whereas with maintained lead you can see the clay constantly. You can see if it slows, or if it drops. He says most newcomers given no tuition will typically revert to a maintained lead style and do 'okay' off the bat.
He also says however, use what works for you, and that different targets might make you more comfortable with a different method, but if you're struggling use it as an opportunity to try a new method which will take several goes before you get used to the new one. However those several goes giving the new method a go are no different to the several goes you'll take missing with your current method.
I use maintained lead for pretty much all targets except teals.
I personally wouldn't discount any method as easy or hard. I bet there is a champion shooter to give merit to every conceivable style. There's even a champion over in America which shoot with one eye shut. Mention shooting one eyed on a UK ground and they'll be plenty of people scoff and say you won't do well without both eyes open.
I'll have a look for those CompX 28s and see what they're like.
Well, my *natural* instinctive shooting was like everyone else's -- maintained lead -- and I agree it 'works' however you hit a wall when trying the really long targets. Like a 50 yard battue as you can get on fitasc. No amount of maintained lead will help you there. I was very, very frustrated when I discovered that as I thought I was doing 'ok' shooting wise, and I couldn't hit a barn door at 40+ yards. Even the very long flat crossers were a problem.
And, I narrowed it down to... maintained lead. On very long birds, if you do maintained lead, your gun barely moves, therefore you end up 'rifling' or aiming the gun, with near zero gun speed... therefore any movement or twitch when you pull the trigger gets amplified and very soon even the large pattern no longer helps you and you miss.. that is, even if you had the lead right -- for me there is too much time to 'think' and thinking is.. bad!
When I discovered the pull away method, I thought it was plain magic. i started hitting these long battues, and I've started to use that method on pretty much everything else. Basically that's also how I hit driven birds anyway (pick the line behind the bird, pull thru and shoot without seeing the bird). My shooting improved significantly since i've switched to the pull away method.
Pretty much everytime I miss now, is when I get a bit 'confident' and think I know where the bird is and revert to maintained lead. It just won't work for me at this stage of my shooting, it's just too easy to screw up.
I also tried the Bidwell method (a little bit, to be honest), but the /key/ to that method is /not to lead the bird/ really, so it's almost like pull away save that your gun moves to the shooting point as you mount, so you get the 'gun speed' from that movement. If you hesitate or wobble as you mount, you're done for! Again, you need to be pretty steady with your gun mount to get it perfectly right all the time. With the 'pull away' method, I get a chance to wobble the mount a bit, and correct it, then pull the line thru the bird.
The reason that gun speed is important is that you 'manufactured' gun movement, and gun movement is good because the inertia you put into the gun will buffer any twitching you migth get. That's also why people want/need longer, heavier guns and swear they shoot better. The 'longer barrels' don't help that much, but the weight does. You can achieve the same with just a bit more inertia in the gun.
BTW, I'm just making things up here, I'm no champion, just an engineer who likes overthinking stuff
![Wink ;-) ;-)](/styles/default/xenforo/vbSmilies/Normal/wink.gif)