I really hate these people who have "x, y and z MMO experience". Most of his argument is that it doesn't run well on his PC - great, buy a better one. Just because it is a "quad core" doesnt mean it will run well. I have had no problems with everything maxed out.
This MMO will be around for a long time - it is Star Trek after all.
Just sounds like he wants to go back to EVE.
"Most of his argument?" I count four sentenses (About 1/5th) of a post that summarises most of my feelings.
Warning: Minor wall of text.
It's all very well shooting down someones argument with facts and honest opinions, but deriding someone for wanting to go back to a more polished and established game is immature. And there are plenty examples in this thread.
My problem is the game lacks depth. So you get a mission from someone, go out there, blow up a few ships, if you're lucky (Or unlucky?) beam down and kill a few NPC's, then warp back out and to starbase.
This would be fun if the missions were unique and "fun". As it is, the systems are generic; different organisation of the same pieces. Asteroids, derelict stations, asteroids with derelict stations on them, gas clouds, and a planet there for the sake of prettyness. In every single system.
The fact that you can't explore the systems makes things worse. There's a warp in point and a mission complete point. Beyond that there's nothing to do, and it would in fact surprise me if the actual map boundaries (The invisible walls!) go far beyond the "play area".
The ground combat is not fun. It's clunky, doesn't feel like anything is happening, at the moment extremely buggy (The amount of times I've seen the death animation, and the very next frame the person has just stood up and started shooting again is unreal). and whenever you get a loot drop with a new item the most excitement I can muster up is "'kay". Add to the fact that the game is so easy at the moment and it just amplifies that feeling.
The other problem is the overuse of instancing. This is down to two things imo - a lack of desire to spend much effort designing a trully open and free roaming space (Like EVE, which I recognise is a brilliant game, even if I cant get into it), and a lack of time, considering that Cryptic only acquired the license in early 2008. It is my opinion that a space MMO cannot feel like one without being open, without the possibility of being lost or feeling far from home, without the possibility of coming across something new and exciting (See previous two paragraphs).
Everytime I cross from one area of sector space to another (A trully unacceptable form of instancing due to the complete and utter lack of things to see and do, it's a glorified top down "map" for crying out loud, how much instancing does it need?!) I can't help but sigh as I realise that the same thing awaits me on the other side.
If the game has one redeeming feature it's the space combat. I do enjoy running circles around the enemy, strafing and dodging as I decide which weapons to use while frantically micro-managing my shields. It's just a shame that every battle is the same, and part of the same system "exploration" cycle.
I'm keeping my preorder as I got mine in back when a certain place had it at £18, and I have no doubt that there may be an enjoyable game here for me a few months down the line. But I won't be playing it until the game has matured and the first few content patches have been deployed. Bugs and lag are one thing, and remotely acceptible for an MMO this early in it's life. However things to do, and a general lack of feelings and ideals that make up what it is you're trying to emulate is not. The developers have promised stuff coming up, but not much of is beyond adding a few more sectors of space and adding a few more different types of ship to fight (There really isn't that much difference between the existing ones).
And please, don't take this the wrong way; as soon as they improve the general quality AND quantity of content, as well as hopefully reduce the instancing to trully make this feel like a space game, I'll be back there playing it as I LOVE Star Trek.
If you're finding the game fun, then great. Please, go in there and enjoy yourself, after all it's a game that lots of people have been looking forward to for a while. Personally, for me it's a massive disappointment in it's current state.
Thank you for your time.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8852d/8852d2062d7110393ceea768b048b31c5d4853ef" alt="Stick Out Tongue :p :p"