I would debate whether Herrera was a "premium" player when he arrived at 24 ish - he is probably at his peak around now. He was a very good acquisition which hasn't worked out as well as hoped (individual games he has been excellent but his form has had massive peaks and troughs unfortunately). Impossible to know how Depay and Martial would adapt to this league so its fair to say they were rather speculative - esp Depay given the level he was playing at previously. I would question Shaw being speculative though given his experience at Southampton - it was just really unfortunate he got the double leg break in what really looked like it could be his break out season , and he has never been the same since. Just really awful for him, and now looks like terrible for the board as well , because even if he is given a massive chance by JM this season, he would have to be absolutely spectacular (and even then its hard to blame him if he were to walk away from OT next summer for nothing after how JM treated him last season).
At least it looks like we will roughly get the money back from Darmian and Blind this summer (makes a change after getting rinsed for most transfers out of the club in past windows)
I know its different times and stuff but if you consider Vidic and Evra cost a combined fee of what Rojo did...….I wouldn't say its "decent enough for that money" at all. He is as bad as Jones and Smalling in my book, occasionally good, but generally bang average or worse. All three have been at OT far too long just laughable how they have survived this long. I would happily sell two of the three of them this summer even if it means bringing just one CB in while promoting one or two U23s
At least (when the time comes) Utd should make some money off Romero - but highly unlikely it will be this summer.
A lot of the press last season have been praising Woodward for the "one year" extentions he has been negotiating into contracts since he came in - personally I always thought If the club is umming and aahh ''ing after 3 or 4 years of having a player at this level, surely they aren't the player we originally thought. (look at the squad 5 years later....a great many of them have gained extensions after not being that great - the board should be making the hard decisions quicker - not delaying them for another season). Otherwise you end up with a squad full of average players and Utd don't hit their performance targets.
On a slightly more jovial note......a transfer from Liverpool to Man Utd has happened this summer...…...in the Womens division (s) ...Siobhan Chamberlain has joined Utd's newly formed team managed by Ex Lioness Casey Stoney