Crap choice, Simon's not at all a good thinker. I think he masks a lot of things with big words, and fancy features and a lot of waffling. He doesn't tackle problems head on, he says he does, he doesnt. The design was not at all good in my opinion. From a person who lives in London, love's highrise archicture and does it as a hobby, i'll be vain and say I consider my knowldge in that field to be more than what is expected of me at my age.
The floorplates of the design will not attract tenants. The tenants he is going for, mainly office, will not come through. If this buildig was built, it will not be built in time for the London property cycle come 2011. In that time the big companies that are looking for office space would have taken Shard: London Bridge, 122 Leadenhall, Heron Tower, Riverside South, More London or Cheapside & London Wall.
Kristina's design had flaws but was better out of the two. It used whole site. It tapered in from the back, not giving an overbearing intimidating look but enough to make the most return. The fact that she decided to base most of it on residential was very very clever. The Square Mile needs residentials. The Southbank is the hotspot for this. Why? It's there to rival Canary Wharf just down the road. The residential units will sell like hotcakes. Stick Shangri La Hotels in there whilst your at it and to be quite honest, she would have seen more return on what she expected.