The Expanse
- Thread starter clockwork.satan
- Start date
Caporegime
I feel like S4 was too small in scope, we basically spent most of the series on a single planet.
Remember that the books and by extension the series, are 3 small mini trilogies for an overarching 9 book run.
Season 1-3 was part 1, Season 4 was act 1 of the new trilogy and was setting up the ground work. Take this from someone who's read the books, there is a lot more great stuff to come.
I will say there was some needless filler in S4 with Bobbies story, didn't gel with that at all. Also I class book 4 as one of my favourites, it was a refreshing change of scenery but that didn't translate well to screen.
Season 4 was based on the book I enjoyed the least, and as expected it was the season I enjoyed the least so far. Having said that, it was still damn good TV.
Sometimes feel like i'm the only one in the world who really enjoyed book 4
Don't get me wrong I did enjoy it, especially the return of one of my favorite characters, but I think it was the weakest of what is a fantastic series of books.
Soldato
Also posted this in the other Expanse thread... in US TV show section.
Watched S5 E1 earlier, 2 and 3 later on this evening with a beer.
It was okay but as I mused earlier, the Books 5 and 6 really start to diversify the story across several different arenas and while this works on the written page, didn't quite (IMHO) nail it, at least not in Ep1. Seemed very rushed as they were trying to cram everything in and, if you hadn't got round to reading Book 5, you might have struggled where the story elements were going.
Watched S5 E1 earlier, 2 and 3 later on this evening with a beer.
It was okay but as I mused earlier, the Books 5 and 6 really start to diversify the story across several different arenas and while this works on the written page, didn't quite (IMHO) nail it, at least not in Ep1. Seemed very rushed as they were trying to cram everything in and, if you hadn't got round to reading Book 5, you might have struggled where the story elements were going.
And in the book Naomi does not explain in any great detail to Holden about why and where she is going as regards Fillip, she just ups and goes. If they were going to trim anything, it should probably have been Alex's back story particularly as I understand the TV show has written the character out for the 6th Season, due to Cas Anwar's (alleged) fall from grace and they CBA to recast).
Not sure if they're just doing Book 5 or Book 6 as well in the 5th season.
Not sure if they're just doing Book 5 or Book 6 as well in the 5th season.
Associate
- Joined
- 30 Aug 2018
- Posts
- 2,483
I didn’t know this was out! It’s a shame it’s only 3 episodes right now
Episode Air Date Episode Name
1 Wed Dec 16, 2020 Exodus
2 Wed Dec 16, 2020 Churn
3 Wed Dec 16, 2020 Mother
4 Wed Dec 23, 2020 Guagamela
5 Wed Dec 30, 2020 Down and Out
6 Wed Jan 06, 2021 Tribes
7 Wed Jan 13, 2021 Oyedeng
8 Wed Jan 20, 2021 Hard Vacuum
9 Wed Jan 27, 2021 Winnipesaukee
10 Wed Feb 03, 2021 Nemesis Games
1 Wed Dec 16, 2020 Exodus
2 Wed Dec 16, 2020 Churn
3 Wed Dec 16, 2020 Mother
4 Wed Dec 23, 2020 Guagamela
5 Wed Dec 30, 2020 Down and Out
6 Wed Jan 06, 2021 Tribes
7 Wed Jan 13, 2021 Oyedeng
8 Wed Jan 20, 2021 Hard Vacuum
9 Wed Jan 27, 2021 Winnipesaukee
10 Wed Feb 03, 2021 Nemesis Games
Soldato
No, they can't make me wait another week after that ending of episode 3. 
Soldato
After Ep3 I’m more worried how much more of the book they’re going to do a Jackson on. New characters and relationships introduced which are not in the book and not really necessary to advance or enhance the story. Don’t get me wrong, it’s still enjoyable and a spectacle but I just wish the adaptation was a bit tighter to the source material.No, they can't make me wait another week after that ending of episode 3.
Associate
- Joined
- 30 Aug 2018
- Posts
- 2,483
Watched the 3 episodes. I’m enjoying the start of this season more than the last. How much of that is down to my current mindset I don’t know.
I knew ep3 would be the big cliffhanger. 
thats a total lie
Maybe I need to rewatch but at the time it was quite a standout show and seemed to take risks while other sci fi was quite pedestrian. That said, i've not seen it since it's original run mid 90's.
As far as blanket statements go, you are totally wrong...in my opinion of course
Been a year since I read the books and bear in mind i've only watched up to ep 2 and not 3 but I can't recall anything from those two episodes that isn't in the book? Please reply in spoilers for other folks spoiler safety of course
Soldato
Been a year since I read the books and bear in mind i've only watched up to ep 2 and not 3 but I can't recall anything from those two episodes that isn't in the book? Please reply in spoilers for other folks spoiler safety of course
It is implied Amos is Eric’s brother and that the woman who died and he went to see the guy about might have been his mother. Alex visiting the lecture hall then taking the aide out to dinner which was actually a setup is also not in the book. Timeline wise, Amos should be visiting Clarrissa in jail when the asteroids start to fall. The characters interacting with Avasarala and that part of the story don’t relate to events as depicted in the book.
yeah i haven't seen it since since the 90's either - it just seemed to stop.
So, 'maybe' its better than i remember, but i wouldn't take that bet