Skyrim on PC (completed in as much as I have spent a little over 300hrs on it on a single play through and completed the main story as well).
9/10. I have knocked a point off for repetitive voices and spammed speech when you walk around towns. With a high end game like this I would have liked to have seen more voices and more variety in the NPC's speech (they reckon there were over 60 voice actors in the game but to me it feels like only 10?). I would also like to see more variety with enemies. Basically its a few of the same sort rinsed and repeated. Oh and the AI of your 'ehelpers' is bad. They just run in and attack which is very frustrating when you just want to make a stealthy approach. as such I avoided help on all but those quests where it was forced.
Other than that, awesome game. Really enjoyed it.
Deus Ex HR on PC + Missing Link DLC
8/10 - Loved this game as I am a big Deus Ex fan (yes I even played invisible war!) but it had some glaring issues. The first is the woeful AI. Guy finds a dead colleague and freaks out for a few seconds then continues to patrol as normal right past his buddies body
Also I found little need for most of the weapons in the game. I just used a fully upgraded pistol with a laser sight+silencer and and only used typhoon/heavy weps for boss battles. I should point out that I was fully offensive on this play through, and did not use stealth (much). Other than that it was a great mix of stealth and action and was the closest thing to the original so far in my opinion. I like how the game is linear but offers multiple ways to complete an objective based on your augs and play style. It finds a nice balance between linear 'set-pieces' and semi-free roaming to offer a game with pace and direction without you feeling like you are in a Modern Warfare 'tunnel'. I also appreciated the fact it allowed me to quick save and did not force console based checkpoint saves. I did find the story less immersive than the original, however the voice acting was superb. The Skyrim developers could learn a thing or two from the likes of DXHR and ME2. Overall I loved this game, but I am a fan of the series, and of the system shock games before, so I am a
little biased, but I have tried to be fair
Mass Effect 2 on PC
7/10 - Wonderful story (and race history), fantastic voice acting, interesting paragon/renegade aspects and plenty to see and do. However for me it just got too repetitive. Same old linear fight sequences find a bit of cover, shoot the bad guys, find a bit more cover, kill a few more. All that changed was the environment. I would like to have seen more variety, and more use of the battle environments with regard to moving around them. Its the future. Why cant my guy jetpack to high places, or climb on the top of obstacles instead of hiding behind them? Why cant he jump? Why is nearly all of the scenery indestructable with only obvious bright red things being 'explosive'? I mean come on, with all the firepower in some of the battles the battle arena would be torn up big time. I enjoyed the game for the first half maybe even 3/4 but then it just got to the point where I was willing it to end. The only thing that kept me going was the story, and thats a real shame.
Cheers
Buff