The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power (Prime)

Most people are fully aware that big companies 'pay' for good reviews - you only have to look at the recently released Star Wars Outlaws and how disney gave some sweet Disneyland trips and merch etc to youtubers/'influencers'/etc in exchange for high scores.


Yep just like Outlaws (which now looks incredibly mid), and first time round they had a freebie event in Oxford (I don't know if you reacall) for all the big shill channels. And they all came out mysteriously saying all the same things - because they were fed lines to take. It was so obvious.

Oh yeah and the same thing for The Acolyte, lots of Disney friendly creators on trips paid for by Disney with goodie bags etc, all mysteriously loving a show that cratered.
 
Last edited:
Season 2, Episode 1 thoughts (Spoilers!):
oh some of it's out already.

Hard to know when the last few pages are all talking about reviews.

Can't all be bad surely...


nothing goods came out in ages now, so I know ya'll will be watching it anyway.

it's like back in the 90s, nothing good on every channel so you just watch whatever the best thing seems to be, and since fallout there's basically been static on every channel?


First ep down, seemed pretty good to me.
Episode one 7/10
 
Last edited:
I said to myself I would give it a fair watch, putting aside a truly awful S1, and EP1 was much better. I was never engaged or interested at all in S1, but this held my interest for an hour.

On to EP2.
 
Makes me wonder what could have been achieved with such a budget and better writers intent on telling an actual story to begin with, the dialogue was better, no modern politics, no Galadriel being an insufferable cow. They have wisely decided not to double down on antagonising people, and have removed many of the offending elements of S1 (Harfoots, apart from the two remaining). There's some sense of scale and a World there wasn't before, it has become its own version of ME, the costumes and sets were much better, and fair play it did look spectacular far better than S1.

I stand by everything I said about S1, it was awful. I said I would give S2 a fair watch, and I have done and a good opening couple of hours IMO. Pleasantly surprised I did think it was going to be more of the same. HOD had a better S1, this looks to be winning the battle for S2.

It's never going to hit peak GOT or PJ LOTR, and that's a shame given the budget. I didn't find it slow or boring, like S1, and I wasn't constantly taken out of the World like S1. Enjoyed the first 2 hours optimistic for what's to come, let's hope it doesn't fall apart, and maybe we can get some epic Tolkien series made down the line.
 
Meanwhile, I sought out a website that said what I wanted to read and reading it affirmed and further entrenched my opinion :p

I’m looking forward to this. S1 was tarred by an (at times) unlikable protagonist and also juggling too many characters that were introduced without allowing the audience to warm to them (especially compared to the masterful approach to building characters in Game of Thrones). I definitely can’t say it was consistently good. But I quite enjoyed some of the latter episodes when it picked up momentum. I view it a bit like how I felt about ‘The Force Awakens’ - yeah, it was OK, keen for more but it needs to ‘step up’.
 
Last edited:
Nearly 20 minutes into episode 1, does it get any less terrible? cause it really is not good so far.

Was going to say at least they seem to have canned the 3+ minutes of ads in an episode but so far I think the ad was the better bit... (EDIT: 2nd episode has 3 minute of ads...).
 
Last edited:
Ep1 was pretty good. The recap/flashback to S1 was nicely done.

Exactly. I didnt think it was that bad, quite interesting how it

Backtracked to explain how Sauron ended up meeting Galadraiel. So he is basically immortal because he can just reform his body by stealing physical material?
 
Last edited:
Exactly. I didnt think it was that bad, quite interesting how it

Backtracked to explain how Sauron ended up meeting Galadraiel. So he is basically immortal because he can just reform his body by stealing physical material?
I suppose they need to translate the concept into something visual otherwise it wouldn't engage the viewers.
 
I suppose they need to translate the concept into something visual otherwise it wouldn't engage the viewers.

Its not just about engaging to viewers. To a casual viewer i had no clue how he was there and what kind of creature Sauron was. S1 they could have built up that reveal better because unless a character said he is Sauron then we had no clue how that was possible and how he looked so human.

Can anyone explain why he looked like a Elf before he got killed? Was that because he had a absored a Elf host?
 
Last edited:
Its not just about engaging to viewers. To a casual viewer i had no clue how he was there and what kind of creature Sauron was. S1 they could have built up that reveal better because unless a character said he is Sauron then we had no clue how that was possible and how he looked so human.

Can anyone explain why he looked like a Elf before he got killed? Was that because he had a absored a Elf host?
Sauron doesn't
"absorb hosts"

Sauron is almost (but not quite) the embodiment of pure evil. He's not a human, he's an almost immortal spirit.

These are book spoilers, but will possibly be explored this season, so I will spoiler them anyway

In the second age he tricked the Elves in to forging The Rings of Power and appeared to them as an elf called Annatar. From the trailers this looks like what they are going to show us this season. For TV purposes this has all been compacted down, but in the books it took 1000's of years.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Kyo
Back
Top Bottom