Soldato
- Joined
- 18 May 2010
- Posts
- 12,759
I was sat in the dark on my own watching the last episode and that horse back scene freaked me the hell out
The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power (Prime)
- Thread starter LiE
- Start date
Caporegime
- Joined
- 30 Jul 2013
- Posts
- 29,035
Almost like Tolkien wasn't at all consistent and kept changing his mind, adding things retrospectively in later stories etc.
Soldato
- Joined
- 28 Oct 2011
- Posts
- 8,501
And in The Hobbit he described Hobbits as:
And so Gollum found them hours later, when he returned, crawling and creeping down the path out of the gloom ahead. Sam sat propped against the stome, his head dropping sideways and his breathing heavy. In his lap lay Frodo's head, drowned deep in sleep; upon his white forehead lay one of Sam's brown hands,
Yes that definitely screams Hobbits of colour to me.
Maybe Sam and Frodo didn't have access to great washing facilities on their trek to Mordor, where I assume this passage comes from?
Maybe those "long clever brown fingers" had something to do with being gardeners and growers of things? maybe that's what JRRT was alluding to? maybe thinking the reader will make the connection that will bring these never-before-described beings to life?
Maybe?
And so Gollum found them hours later, when he returned, crawling and creeping down the path out of the gloom ahead. Sam sat propped against the stome, his head dropping sideways and his breathing heavy. In his lap lay Frodo's head, drowned deep in sleep; upon his white forehead lay one of Sam's brown hands,
Yes that definitely screams Hobbits of colour to me.
Maybe Sam and Frodo didn't have access to great washing facilities on their trek to Mordor, where I assume this passage comes from?
Maybe those "long clever brown fingers" had something to do with being gardeners and growers of things? maybe that's what JRRT was alluding to? maybe thinking the reader will make the connection that will bring these never-before-described beings to life?
Maybe?
Soldato
- Joined
- 28 Oct 2011
- Posts
- 8,501
Funny how the race miscasting has been brought up again today, but not by the people who disagree with it...it's almost like they're following the amazon gaslighting script!
Caporegime
- Joined
- 30 Jul 2013
- Posts
- 29,035
Well I would prefer to focus on the content of the show, not the melanin of actors skins, but you guys keep bringing it up.
Did he specifically say that there were never any brown hobbits/Elves/Dwarves?
Also, this series is not written or produced by Tolkien is it. It is a new adaptation of his world.
Sounds like you just got immensely triggered by having the absurdity of the Melanin argument ridiculed..
Soldato
- Joined
- 28 Oct 2011
- Posts
- 8,501
He's trying to bait about the race mis-casting because the shows sucks, his post came from nowhere you'll notice. First post of the day, baiting. People who are rightly critical of the show of actually moved on as there's just sooo many terrible aspects to the show.
Soldato
- Joined
- 28 Oct 2011
- Posts
- 8,501
LMAO.
Who was it who mentioned the ethnicity of Arondir?
PS You enjoyed "kung-fu Elf" so much that you didn't know his name? - He's my favourite carcther is oldwhatsisname????
Some debate over harfoots, then again depends on how you want to interpret 'browner than'
yes
his world, his creation, his rules.
And yet it was you that felt the need to bring it up in the 1st place, as to ridiculed, all you've done is interjected current western 21st-century social talking points into a fantasy setting that has established lore.
Soldato
- Joined
- 28 Oct 2011
- Posts
- 8,501
Yeah, but amazon knows better than the author, the 7 decades old fanbase, the scholars, the artists, Peter Jackson and his epic Trilogy...yeah they know better the Kathleen Kennedy clone, the intern-level "showrunners" and the writers of some of the worst dialogue on TV...
They know best, those people.
I think the best thing to do is just ignore when certain posters raise complaints. They're not happy with the show, and that is fine entertainment is subjective, but they can't stay away from the thread to keep bringing up their dislikes. Again, fine, it's a forum for discussion so they're entitled to do so.
I'm looking forward to tomorrows episode as the 3rd episode it felt like things started to pick up a bit. Dodgy horse riding segment aside, it's not been a bad show so far.
I don't forget a face, but I struggle to remember names in general and don't take much interest in names in movies/TV more the character.
Can you quote where Tolkien wrote that there were never any brown elves/dwarves?
"all you've done is interjected current western 21st-century social talking points into a fantasy setting"
My post was literally critising those that use the real worlds biology of melanin as some sort of reason as to why Elves and Dwarves cannot be brown in a fantasy world where the trees walk and talk/wizards and socrcerers exist.
Can you not see how utterly absurd that argument is?
FYI - In the post you quoted I made no reference to any social talking points. I was saying how stupid it was to talk about how the real world's science behind skin pigmentation is somehow relevant to a fantasy world.
Soldato
The "race" issue is interesting, since as they are a travelling folk they would come across far more "foreign" than say the Hobbits they evolved into that basically didn't leave the shire.
The closest real world I guess would be the roman armies, when they set out from Rome they would be Roma italian in effect. By the time they had spent 10 years on conquest they would be multi cultural as they absorbed conquested people into their ranks.
I see this as in effect happening ROP, a travelling community is including some diverse by very similar into their ranks.
But TBH I look past it and attempt to become involved in the story rather than fixating on facial expressions and the colour of people skin.
Soldato
- Joined
- 28 Oct 2011
- Posts
- 8,501
I find it interesting why the shows story-telling, writing, acting, dialogue, pacing, costumes etc are so bad
As for The Harfoots, they take so little care of their own I doubt they would welcome any strangers to their company, as they leave their own to die on the road at the moment they become the slightest potential hindrance...
"We will wait for you" (but only where you're dead).
Hmmm, not really Tolkien's Hobbits these folk are they?
As for The Harfoots, they take so little care of their own I doubt they would welcome any strangers to their company, as they leave their own to die on the road at the moment they become the slightest potential hindrance...
"We will wait for you" (but only where you're dead).
Hmmm, not really Tolkien's Hobbits these folk are they?
Go back into the thread it's already been listed..
Can you point those out? Ive only ever seen folks say that Tolkien gave specific descriptions for the races, which included the colour of their skin, and thats why having <insert brown/black/asian/eskimo/martian> is wrong.
Again, are you able to point these posts out? I've just gone back a week and gave a cursory glance at posts and can't see one single person bring race into it? Or are you just making things up?
Clearly not seeing as they aren’t in the shire. No more than Sméagol was, the one that actually murdered another.
Why do you think i am talking about you or what anyone in this thread has said
You seem to have taken my post very personally!
oh, so you are dredging posts up/talking points from weeks/months ago? Where are you pulling the information from that people are applying real world's science behind skin pigmentation to this particular show?Why do you think i am talking about you or what anyone in this thread has said
I was commenting on all the stupid twitter, reddit etc posts i have seen, talking about how Dwraves and Elves cannot be black because of how melanin works in the real word.
You have then seemingly gone on a rant about stuff that wasnt even that related to what i wrote.