** The Official Space Flight Thread - The Space Station and Beyond **

Soldato
Joined
14 Sep 2008
Posts
3,811
Location
Nottingham
Heard about that a while on a few of the pods I listen to.
Nice to see nasa and the international agencies are making the appropriate noises.

More amazing reading through the article over science alert, the amount of on world applications of the em drive. It works all the stuff they mention, needs to happen!
 
Soldato
Joined
16 Jun 2013
Posts
5,375
:eek: let's just hope it scales well as iirc the previous version was producing micro Newtons of thrust. Somewhat worrying that the brightest minds haven't figured out why yet lol.
 
Soldato
Joined
18 Oct 2012
Posts
8,333
Isnt this just the same physical reaction that makes solar sails work, the idea being that just because the particles emitted dont have mass doesnt mean they cant transferr energy.

The big issue is really that this thing will produce such little power yet require a lot of energy to acheive it, not exactly effecient
 
Man of Honour
Joined
11 Mar 2004
Posts
76,634
Isnt this just the same physical reaction that makes solar sails work, the idea being that just because the particles emitted dont have mass doesnt mean they cant transferr energy.

The big issue is really that this thing will produce such little power yet require a lot of energy to acheive it, not exactly effecient

They have no idea how it's creating thrust. And it's not spitting anything out the back.
Also it's extremely efficient as it's not using up anything. Power and low thrust isn't an issue. There's plenty of power in space. These could be used for orientation and position keeping thrusters, which have an unlimited fuel supply.

Or you could launch a probe with a nuclear reactor and let it accelerate for years or decades. as sunlight gets to faint once you get out to the outer planets.
 
Last edited:
Soldato
Joined
2 Aug 2012
Posts
7,809
They have no idea how it's creating thrust. And it's not spitting anything out the back.
Also it's extremely efficient as it's not using up anything. Power and low thrust isn't an issue. There's plenty of power in space. These could be used for orientation and position keeping thrusters, which have an unlimited fuel supply.

Or you could launch a probe with a nuclear reactor and let it accelerate for years or decades. as sunlight gets to faint once you get out to the outer planets.

Indeed,

Power isn't the problem. Propellant/Reaction mass is the problem!

Consider a traditional solid core NTR, the reactor would have enough "Fuel" to operate for months if not years, However the rocket would likely run out of "Propellant" within 10 minutes.

An EM drive doesn't need propellant so will work for as long as you can provide it with electrical power, which might be for decades or even centuries!
 
Back
Top Bottom