Results aren't the whole story.
Greece won it in 2004 ergo Greece had one of the best managers, ever?
It just doesn't work like that.
England in the group stages were
dire to watch. Really awful.
The crux of the question is: should Southgate be able to do better with the player he has at his disposal? And the answer for many of us is "yes".
Anyway I have a feeling he's going to be found out big-style against Italy. His confusing aversion to making timely substitutions will probably be on display once again, as we start with an extremely defensive and negative setup and it fails to work out. Then in the 85th minute he'll bring on Grealish before taking him off in the 87th. Tactical masterclass, I'm expecting
That was the pattern against Croatia last WC. Vardy watching while the lethargic and ineffective Kane lumbered around midfield. Southgate kept him on the whole match.
Here's the team list and sub timings below from that match: 1 sub in the first 90 minutes. 1. When they've equalised at what, 68 minutes?
He swaps Sterling, who looked like he was actually intimidating their defenders, for Rashford at 74, who was easier for them to handle, when it was clear Kane wasn't firing on all fours. In fact he might as well have been on all fours for the contribution he was making in the 2nd half.
Vardy didn't get on until ET, when they had gone ahead and were closing ranks, and with next to no time to do anything anyway.
Yeah, great tactics, don't use the player who is best against a high line until they park-the-bus and go 6-3-1?
If felt like Southgate was playing for penalties in ET until they scored their second. e.g. He brought on Eric Dier for Henderson at 97 minutes. the other changes were to preserve the formation, Rose for young etc. There's no change in system when it goes 1-1, nothing to show an intent beyond "I've got my plan and I'm sticking to it" which is fine, so long as that plan works. If they figure it out and you don't adapt, then in the words of the great the prophet Hudson "that's game over man, game over."
England team (V Croatia 2018)
- 1Pickford
- 2Walker Booked at 54mins, Substituted for Vardy at 112'minutes
- 5Stones
- 6Maguire
- 8Henderson Substituted for Dier at 97'minutes
- 12Trippier scored at 5 minutes
- 7Lingard
- 20Alli
- 18Young Substituted for Rose at 90'minutes
- 9Kane
- 10Sterling Substituted for Rashford at 74'
Next we have Scotland England 2021. He uses two subs. Two out of five. Content with a draw clearly!
- 1Pickford
- 24James
- 5Stones
- 15Mings
- 3Shaw
- 14Phillips
- 4Rice
- 19Mount
- 20Foden Substituted for Grealish at 63'minutes
- 9Kane Substituted for Rashford at 74'minutes
- 10Sterling
At least he subbed Kane this time, but Foden looked the most lively and was asking questions of them. Grealish needed to come on, but Foden wasn't the player to take off to achieve that IMO!