No because the second goal should have been after you had at least two sent off (and they should have gone before Vidic went off)
Either Carragher goes off or Owen at the very least tests Reina
Plus Giggs penalty in the first half
Lots of if's and but's. Who's to say what might have been had 'x' been given. Carra could have gone but that's not to say that we wouldn't have scored again or that Vidic or Masch would have gone later either. The Giggs penalty was never going to be a penalty, just like when Kuyt had his shirt practically ripped off his back it was not likely to be given. Those sort of challenges just don't get picked up on in the box.
The fact of the matter is that over the 90+ minutes, we created considerably more opportunities to score and with better finishing it could have easily been a bigger scoreline.