Soldato
- Joined
- 2 Feb 2010
- Posts
- 11,138
- Location
- Crowmarsh
I don’t get the love for Rogue One at all. It’s split into three very distinct and linear segments and is quite boring on a rewatch particularly ‘Planet X’ and ‘Planet Y’ - only third planet ‘Z’ with the antenna is a bit more interesting. The supporting ‘monk’ and ‘heavy weapon’ characters are a bit rubbish and super cliched. The robot is awesome though.
I think RO gets a little overpraised because people like the grittier vibe and the darker moments (notably Vader going nuts) which is fun and novel but overall it just feels too... narrow and dry, to me.
I actually preferred Solo... but in that film I’m definitely docking points for that annoying robot. Definitely the worst character in any SW film.
It gets praise because it isn't utterly terrible like the other Disney star wars films
It's the only half decent one since 1983...