What Modular PSU to get?

the 620w corsair can be had for £81inc. cheapest i can find the 850w coolermaster is £105 on the bay. im talking about the 850w CM. you must be talking about the 620w. do you have any reviews for it?
 
Last edited:
I've always like thermaltake psu' as well, haven't got any of there new ones though. But I assume there still very high standards.

jsut read some reviews the Thermaltake ToughPower 850W Modular is an awesome psu, however it does come in at just over a £100
 
Last edited:
Stupid question, but why don't Enermax's get a vote? They seem pretty good (use them myself) but not really kept up with the times. Is it a value factor, because back in the day they were the dogs danglies..
 
well I 've got my eye on a Tagan 1100 for around £120

thermaltake are pretty solid as well... they would be my second choice

PS. p4radox the rest of the system was an x2 3800, asus mobo and 2 hds.. not much really.. still with oblivion that is a heavy game for gfx after a while it would crash to desktop.

added a 2nd 350w psu and problem solved (it feeds the GTX and all lights, fans, etc)
 
James are you feeling ok? The 620W coolermaster is on OCUK for £78.71 inc VAT, beats your corsair for value

yes and the corsair can be had for £79.99 INCLUDING delivery. thats why i said about the same.

if your going to be anal, the hx620 is actually cheaper delivered:)
 
Last edited:
yes and the corsair can be had for £79.99 INCLUDING delivery. thats why i said about the same.

if your going to be anal, the hx620 is actually cheaper delivered:)

Lol. Calm down mate, I was just trying to broaden your horizon - rather than you be a corsair fanboy all your life
 
Lol. Calm down mate, I was just trying to broaden your horizon - rather than you be a corsair fanboy all your life

oh right ok. so you try and tell me the coolermaster is cheaper, as if to prove a point, and when i show you it isnt you change tact?

i will recommend the best for the job for the money. no more no less. If you think that makes me a fanboy, you havent got a clue mate:)

Stupid question, but why don't Enermax's get a vote? They seem pretty good (use them myself) but not really kept up with the times. Is it a value factor, because back in the day they were the dogs danglies..

they used to be solid psu's. the had some trouble around 2005 though, and the corsair Hx's came out some time mid2006. they they are back on track now from what ive been reading. perhaps we are just waiting for that next killer psu from them? :)
 
Last edited:

Hello XeNoN89, a power supply such as the Corsair HX 520W ATX2.2 Modular SLI Compliant PSU will be absolutely fine for the system that you have specified. Though I would recommend purchasing the Corsair HX 620W model to give you that bit extra headroom.

To give you more of an idea of what sort of power consumption the system that you are looking at purchasing will be:

From what we can gather from sources so far, the maximum power consumption of the Nvidia GTX 280 is around 240 watts which equates to 20 amps. The Intel Q9450 at stock will pull around 100 watts which equals to 9 amps. Now, I am not 100 percent sure of the power consumption of the Intel Q9450 when overclocked. However, an Intel Q6600 overclocked to 3.3GHz draws around 150 watts which equates to 13 amps and is slightly more power hungry than the Intel Q9450 so if we use that as a rough guide. Then, if we add a couple of hard drives into the equation rated at one amp each and then some for he extra headroom, you are looking at around 38 amps.

The Corsair HX 520W would power the above system absolutely fine as already said. However, it does leave you little headroom if you for example, wish to add any more hard drives in the future and I would personally advise going for the Corsair HX 620W model which will be perfectly fine. :)

Its the same thing with the 8800GT, everyone recommends it no matter what, yet there are still better cards out there.

Hello icey_ha, Coolermaster power supplies are by no means poor units, they are actually pretty reasonable for the price. However, they aren't quite as good in comparison to the equivalent Corsair power supply units.

Take the Coolermaster Real Power 520w Modular Power Supply which can deliver 34 amps on the +12Volt rail. (Which is essentially one of the most important things you must look for when looking at purchasing a power supply unit because it provides power to the more demanding powered components in your system like the Processor, Graphics Card and Hard Drives) Compare that particular Coolermaster unit to the Corsair HX 520W ATX2.2 Modular SLI Compliant PSU which can deliver 40 amps on the +12Volt rail.

Now, why anyone would then recommend the Coolermaster Real Power 520w power supply over that of the Corsair HX 520W is beyond me.

People don't recommend the Corsair power supplies because they are so called "fan boys" or they want to annoy people but because they are extremely well made and reliable units. :)


Hello grs_link, I would be very much inclined to think that you may of had a faulty power supply unit because their is absolutely no way the Corsair HX 520W would struggle running a system that consisted of a AMD X2 3800+, Nvidia 8800 GTX and a couple of hard drives.

A single Nvidia 8800 GTX consumes around 170 watts which equates to 14 amps. Now, the AMD Athlon 64 X2 Dual Core 3800+ will consume a maximum off 100 watts which equals to 9 amps. If we then add a couple of hard drives into the system rated at one amps each and then some for the overhead, the system will be pulling around 30 amps and even then, that's over compensating quite a bit. :)

they used to be solid psu's. the had some trouble around 2005 though, and the corsair Hx's came out some time mid2006. they they are back on track now from what ive been reading. perhaps we are just waiting for that next killer psu from them? :)

Hello james.miller, I'm sure you are aware that Enermax have released some newer type of power supply fairly recently, the Enermax Modu 82+ and the Enermax Pro 82+ series. Reading one of the reviews on Anandtech about them, which can be found here, it would seem that they are brilliant power supplies and would certainly be a worthy purchase. Also, from what I can gather, the cabling is of slightly higher quality compared to the Corsair units and it would also seem that they are the quietest power supplies currently on the market.

Anandtech said:
The Enermax Pro82+ and Modu82+ both perform extremely well in our tests, and as such we are awarding both series our Gold Editors' Choice Award. Users can't go wrong with these power supplies, and silence (without going fanless) has been redefined today. Enermax truly has the quietest air-cooled power supplies in the market right now, and the prices (at least for the smaller versions at the moment) make these units relatively affordable and very attractive.

However, they are slightly more expensive in comparison to the the equivalent Corsair units. :)
 
Last edited:
Wow fire hazard, what a long post. Good bit of information. Thing is I haven't exactly researched the specs of the coolermaster and the corsair, all I wanted to do is for someone to stop recommending the corsair all the time. It gets a bit boring that everyone recommends it when someone asks a PSU question.

I felt the same with the 8800GT, it got/gets on my nerves how people keep recommending it.

Oh, and for my next build i'll try the corsair. Then I can first hand compare the two.
 
Fire wizzard... I bet that keyboard went on fire for a phile there :P

....and to the matter at hand... I just wanted to make another point here,

have in mind that most power supply units work their best at around 50-60%
and it is always better to have more than u need as psu is not an uprade you do often,
atleast no to my experience (I mean mine has driven 5 to 6 motherboards and plenty of cpus) so get something that is future proof.

I don't know how much is the price playing a role in ** decision but I would strongly recommend a price range of 100 to 150.
but in case that money is an issue then I would have to agree that corsair 's 650w is the best choice here.

at the end of the day, I hope whatever you get to cover ** needs and more.
 
If you don't mind spending around £100 on a PSU.. the Seasonic M12 700W is a good bet.

If you'd like something a bit cheaper, go for the Corsair HX620, which is also manufactured by Seasonic.
 
I just bought a new coolermaster Real Power 700w Modular Power Supply for £57.95 + £9.49 del which seems pretty good value to me seeing as they are £84.59 inc VAT +del at overclockers.
I got it cos the reviews i read were really good anyone else got one ? if so what do they think of it ?

Andy
 
520 won't be enough... It wasn't for me even with an 3800x2

the moment I plugged in my 8800GTX system was rebooting during gaming.

I recommend you get a 750w minimum.... just to be futureproof...
maybe u wanna sli or crossfire later on... u cant go wrong with more

I'm running a GTS G92 oc'd, a Q6600, two opitcal drives, 4 hard drives, a couple of pci cards, a d5 water pump all off a 480W psu so I am surprised 520 wasn't enough for your GTX.
 
Back
Top Bottom