Where do I stand on this RMA?

Status
Not open for further replies.
My recent system build had a slightly bent pin and it still worked , but it was showing 4GB of RAM instead of 6GB of RAM.

So i bent the offending pin back to position and not having a problem since.



Interesting, thanks for the information.:)
 
So I saw your MSE post to be honest might be slightly too techy for there so...

You may have some protection through the Visa Debit not sure how much. You could try to fix the board yourself (not best option), you could go to small claims court for the price of the motherboard but not sure how the warranty works or is worded.

It's surprising that OcUk didn't change the motherboard in good faith though as they can probably RMA it as faulty themselves and get a replacement. I honesty don't see how you'd've damaged the pins without frelling the whole board though those who potter rarely by pre-clocked systems where's the margin that overclocking would provide?
 
Last edited:
I hope ocuk can sort this out, as I’m a loyal customer and always buy my stuff here because their support and service is normally excellent but unfortunately this has happened :(

I'm still not sure whether to sign for the package when it comes tomorrow seeing how I don’t agree this is my fault..
 
hi guys

at the risk of OcUK looking bad over this, and the post and webnote history being made public, i feel that it is only fair that the evidence is posted to back this up.

IMG_8191.jpg


IMG_8190.jpg


Extra heat (Well within specs!) can move the pins, so pins which were only barely touching start moving under load, and then skip off the pads. Repeated thermal expansion and contraction can move it microns at a time, never going back into quite the same place!

not like this they dont

IMG_8189.jpg


IMG_8188.jpg


overclocked bundles are sent with the cpu preinstalled.
in order for them to pass QC they have to pass stress testing and be fully functional.
the board would not work in this condition. you mention you had it working.

i really do wish there was something we could do to help.
but the damage means that the item is warranty void.

the manufacturer would reject this board immediately to us which means we are unable to provide a replacement.

if you wish for me to move the thread to the private customer service forum to save embarrasment then please let me know
 
So OCUK is unwilling to even consider the fact that it might have:

A) Been damaged in shipping.
B) Been damaged by OCUK - you have after all removed the CPU from it's socket to take photo's and it could easily have been damaged during this process.
C) Slipped past your quality control and may not have been tested at all.
 
@ the OP, the bent pin might be a red herring, do you have a meaty enough PSU for that kit?

edit: ignore me, read your signature, 600w is ample, I run mine with a GTX470 on a 500W Akasa.
 
So OCUK is unwilling to even consider the fact that it might have:

A) Been damaged in shipping.
B) Been damaged by OCUK - you have after all removed the CPU from it's socket to take photo's and it could easily have been damaged during this process.
C) Slipped past your quality control and may not have been tested at all.

i wouldnt go as far to say they are facts, more guesses.

A. the courier would have had to open a sealed package, bend the pins and put it back. that is very very unlikely

B. the pins were damaged and the board didnt post. we see this time and time again. curious customers taking the cpu out for a peek. it could not have been easily damaged by simply removing a cpu.

C. i personally do all OcUK bundles. they are quality controlled by a technical manager before leaving the building. each item is individually scanned off as functional before the consignment can leave. our quality control is tight for a reason, so we are protected agains claims such as these.
 
If it wasn't damaged by you and OCUK are saying it wasn't them then the fault lies with the courier, that being the case the responsibility is still OCUK's, not yours, get on to consumer direct about it.

http://www.consumerdirect.gov.uk/

How is it the fault of the courier? I think it is safe to say that it would be impossible for the pins to be damaged in transit with the CPU and heatsink compressing them. You'd have to have some serious damage to the retention mechanism which would be easily visable for the CPU to come out of its socket with the HSF on top of it.
 
i wouldnt go as far to say they are facts, more guesses.

A. the courier would have had to open a sealed package, bend the pins and put it back. that is very very unlikely

The Radon bundle you sold me wasn't exactly "sealed", there was a bit of sellotape over the box, motherboard box was unsealed too with the processor seated.
 
How is it the fault of the courier? I think it is safe to say that it would be impossible for the pins to be damaged in transit with the CPU and heatsink compressing them. You'd have to have some serious damage to the retention mechanism which would be easily visable for the CPU to come out of its socket with the HSF on top of it.

If you want to believe the OP and OCUK who's left?
 
if you wish for me to move the thread to the private customer service forum to save embarrasment then please let me know

No, Please keep this thread here.

The board would not work in this condition. you mention you had it working.

Yes I mentioned I had it working, it did/does work I was just getting random freezes and random BSOD as I’ve stated already.

So OCUK is unwilling to even consider the fact that it might have:

A) Been damaged in shipping.
B) Been damaged by OCUK - you have after all removed the CPU from it's socket to take photo's and it could easily have been damaged during this process.
C) Slipped past your quality control and may not have been tested at all.

Yes I find it unbelievable that OCUK is 100% flat-out refusing to consider anything other than it did not happen before I received it.

I understand it's very unlikely to be the courier's fault
 
Last edited:
The Radon bundle you sold me wasn't exactly "sealed", there was a bit of sellotape over the box, motherboard box was unsealed too with the processor seated.

the returned box was sealed.
that is not what is in question here.

the op has had the pc functional. the return was created after a period of time which suggests the damage was caused after a period of functionallity.

this suggests that the bundle was delivered in full working condition.

this damage has happend whilst it is in the OPs possesion. the board would not function in this condition.
 
i wouldnt go as far to say they are facts, more guesses.

That would by why I used the word 'might'.

A. the courier would have had to open a sealed package, bend the pins and put it back. that is very very unlikely

Fair enough.

B. the pins were damaged and the board didnt post. we see this time and time again. curious customers taking the cpu out for a peek. it could not have been easily damaged by simply removing a cpu.

Maybe, but how did you know the pins were bent before removing the CPU and how do you know that it wasn't that removal process that bent the pins, I'm sorry but everybody makes mistakes and it could just as easily have been OCUK during this process.

C. i personally do all OcUK bundles. they are quality controlled by a technical manager before leaving the building. each item is individually scanned off as functional before the consignment can leave. our quality control is tight for a reason, so we are protected agains claims such as these.

Ah, the old infallable system claim, I've heard that one before. Is this the same system that recieves fantasy phonecalls from your clients?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom