Whoever you support, which players would you like your club to sign from Italy?

wedgie22 said:
BoomAM, as you clearly didn't read this comment first time around there it is again. Strange comment from someone using all their effort to prove otherwise wouldn't you say?

The only point I am trying to prove is that if any of the players from the clubs involved want to leave, there is nothing that the club can do to stop them. That includes Milan, whether you think otherwise or not.

This fantasy world you live in where any club can hold a player against their will just doesn't exist.
Click to expand...
Good one that. Fantasy world. Originality. :o
So even though Milan have actually said that they're going to MAKE players respect their contract, your correct? lol. Ok then.
If the contract is 1-2years, then they'll get made to respect it, if their contract is above that, then its likely some sort of compromise will be made.
 
BoomAM said:
Good one that. Fantasy world. Originality. :o
So even though Milan have actually said that they're going to MAKE players respect their contract, your correct? lol. Ok then.
If the contract is 1-2years, then they'll get made to respect it, if their contract is above that, then its likely some sort of compromise will be made.
Click to expand...
Boom i think your missing the point; he's not talking about Milan specifically, he is saying, like i was saying earlier, that it is nearly impossible for a club to keep hold of a player that wants to move.
And off subject; i really think you have too much faith in what anybody related to Milan says; just because they are directors/players for Milan doesn't mean there telling the truth. Even when a club wants to sell its players it still will say we want to keep them to get a better price et. BTW im not saying thats the case with Milan.
 
BaZ87 said:
Boom i think your missing the point; he's not talking about Milan specifically, he is saying, like i was saying earlier, that it is nearly impossible for a club to keep hold of a player that wants to move.
And off subject; i really think you have too much faith in what anybody related to Milan says; just because they are directors/players for Milan doesn't mean there telling the truth. Even when a club wants to sell its players it still will say we want to keep them to get a better price et. BTW im not saying thats the case with Milan.
Click to expand...

Spot on. BoomAM seems to think Milan operate in a different way to all the other great clubs in europe, as if what applies to Barca, Madrid etc doesn't apply to Milan. All I am saying is Milan are no different to all the other clubs, as he keeps unintentionally proving in his posts. Everything BoomAM said about Milan not selling their best players etc applies to all the top clubs in europe. All the other top clubs also makes claims about not selling star players too.

As I have said before, I do think that quite a few players will stay at their clubs, and of those clubs involved Milan have the best chance of keeping their top players. Like it or not however, if a player decides he wants out of Milan or any club, then he will leave, that is how the real world operates. It's probably true to say that shouldn't be the case and contracts should be honoured, but that's how football works.
 
wedgie22 said:
...snip...
Click to expand...
Im yet to see you list this vast list of star players leaving Milan. ;)

Most clubs do operate the same, but, as ive said, Milan rarely sell their star players. This isnt opinion. This is fact. And im sure that we wouldnt be having this discussion if Sheva hadnt recently been sold. But notice my first sentance of this paragraph. Notice the usage of 'rarely'.
:o
 
Can you please show a quote of me saying I was going to offer a vast list of players leaving Milan? Once again you think it's all about Milan, the list you refer to was infact of players who left their club (any club) yet the club did not want to sell.

I would like to also point out again the reason Milan and all the other top clubs don't sell their best players is because it would be mad to ask to leave a club such as Milan without a very good reason. Not that I am saying players will now be asking to leave Milan, just that they may and if they do then they will go.
 
wedgie22 said:
Can you please show a quote of me saying I was going to offer a vast list of players leaving Milan?
Click to expand...
You claimed you could:
wedgie22 said:
I'm sure if I looked it up I would find many more examples.
Click to expand...
Wether you ment that in regard to one club, or in general is up for interpritation.
But, ive yet to see you list any either way.

Once again you think it's all about Milan,
Click to expand...
Yes i do.
I started my end of the discussion with Milan in mind, so thats what im discussing.

I dont plan on conceeding my end, and i doubt you will yours. So take whatever impression you want from this discussion because im not spending all day discussing.
I'll hand you one thing though. Your sarcastic comments even made me chuckle. :p
 
BoomAM said:
Wether you ment that in regard to one club, or in general is up for interpritation.
But, ive yet to see you list any either way.
Click to expand...

I wouldn't say it was up for interpritation at all. Of the 6 transfers I named only 1 invloved Milan so I think it was pretty clear I was refering to all clubs.

Do I really need to do give other examples? I'll give 2 more off the top of my head:

Essien to Chelsea (seem to remember the Lyon president saying he would not be sold for less than £32m)
Andy Johnson to Everton

I have said all along I expect Milan to keep most if not all of their best players, so in that way I agree with you. Where we disagree is Milan would not be able to keep them if they decided they wanted to leave, and you think they would be able to force them to stay.
 
wedgie22 said:
I have said all along I expect Milan to keep most if not all of their best players, so in that way I agree with you. Where we disagree is Milan would not be able to keep them if they decided they wanted to leave, and you think they would be able to force them to stay.
Click to expand...
We'll have to agree to disagree then. :o
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom