Just to join in here., starting with I agree with this point as far as stability goes, but then Windows 7 improved on both speed and usability. UAC's reduced prompting being a good example of this. Many people do describe Windows 7 however as "What Vista should have been."
Really? Definitely do not agree here. In what way is 8 to 8.1 more of an upgrade than Windows Vista to 7?
Yes Windows 8 is more of a hybrid than previous versions of Windows, but they could have made the changeover less alienating to their PC user base. At least Windows 10 seems to be them showing they have learned from their mistakes however. Well, some of them anyway.
You are completely missing the point here. Do you really pin everything in the control panel to the desktop? Every little tweak and setting change throughout the OS? You are right that UI use in general is very subjective, but this is not what Rroff is pointing out.
One thing I miss in Windows 8 (and sadly does not appear to have returned in 10) is how easy it is to manage past and present wireless networks in Windows 7 and to change from Private to Public networks (and vice versa).